Pourel Nicolas, Santelmo Nicola, Naafa Nidal, Serre Antoine, Hilgers Werner, Mineur Laurent, Molinari Nicolas, Reboul François
Radiation Oncology Department, Institut Sainte-Catherine, France.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2008 May;33(5):829-36. doi: 10.1016/j.ejcts.2008.01.063. Epub 2008 Mar 25.
Optimal preoperative treatment of stage IIB (Pancoast)/III non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) remains undetermined and a subject of controversy. The goal of our study is to confirm feasibility and pathological response rates after induction chemoradiation (CRT) in our community-based treatment center.
Patients were selected according to functional and resectability criteria. Induction treatment comprised 3D conformal 4500 cGy radiotherapy delivered to the primary tumor and pathologic hilar and/or mediastinal lymph nodes on CT scan with an extra-margin of 1-1.5 cm. Concurrent chemotherapy regimen was cisplatinum 20mg/m2 d1-d5 and etoposide 50mg/m2 d1-d5, d1-5 d29-33. Within 3-4 weeks after CRT completion, operability was re-assessed accordingly. Surgery was performed 4-6 weeks after CRT completion in patients (pts) deemed resectable. Inoperable pts were referred for a 20-25 Gy boost +/-1 extra-cycle of cisplatinum+etoposide.
From 1996 to 2005, 107 pts were initially selected for treatment and received induction chemoradiation (stage IIB-Pancoast 18, IIIA 58 and IIIB 31, squamous cell carcinoma 48%, adenocarcinoma 44%, large-cell undifferentiated carcinoma 14%). After preoperative evaluation, 72 pts (67%) had a thoracotomy (pneumonectomy 21, lobectomy 45, bilobectomy 5) and all but one (unresectable tumor) had a macroscopic complete resection. During the 3-month postoperative time, five patients (6.9%) died, four after pneumonectomy (right 3, left 1). The analysis of tumoral samples showed a pathological complete response rate or microscopic residual foci of 39.5%. Median follow-up time was 22.3 months (survivors: 36.8 months), 2-year and 3-year overall survival rates were 55% and 40%, respectively (median=26.7 months) for all the intention-to-treat population (n=107), 62% and 51% (median=36.5 months) for 71 resected pts, 41% and 16% for 36 non-resected pts (median=19.1 months). On multivariate analysis, surgical resection and tumoral necrosis >50% (or pathological complete response) were the most pertinent predictive factors of the risk of death (hazard ratio=0.50 and 0.48, p=0.006 and 0.038, respectively).
Surgery was feasible after induction chemoradiation, particularly lobectomy in PS 0-1, stage IIB (Pancoast)/III NSCLC pts but pneumonectomy carries a high risk of postoperative death (particularly, right pneumonectomy). Pathological response to induction chemoradiation was complete in 39.5% of patients and was a significant predictive factor of overall survival.
IIB期(潘科斯特氏综合征)/III期非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)的最佳术前治疗方案仍未确定,且存在争议。我们研究的目的是在我们的社区治疗中心确认诱导放化疗(CRT)后的可行性和病理缓解率。
根据功能和可切除性标准选择患者。诱导治疗包括对CT扫描显示的原发肿瘤以及病理上的肺门和/或纵隔淋巴结进行三维适形放疗,剂量为4500 cGy,外放边界为1 - 1.5 cm。同步化疗方案为顺铂20mg/m²,第1 - 5天给药;依托泊苷50mg/m²,第1 - 5天、第29 - 33天给药。在完成CRT后的3 - 4周内,相应地重新评估手术可行性。对于被认为可切除的患者,在完成CRT后的4 - 6周进行手术。不可切除的患者接受20 - 25 Gy的追加放疗以及±1个周期的顺铂 + 依托泊苷化疗。
1996年至2005年,最初选择107例患者进行治疗并接受诱导放化疗(IIB期 - 潘科斯特氏综合征18例,IIIA期58例,IIIB期31例,鳞状细胞癌48%,腺癌44%,大细胞未分化癌14%)。术前评估后,72例患者(67%)接受了开胸手术(全肺切除术21例,肺叶切除术45例,双叶切除术5例),除1例(不可切除肿瘤)外,其余均实现了肉眼下完全切除。在术后3个月内,5例患者(6.9%)死亡,4例在全肺切除术后死亡(右侧3例,左侧1例)。肿瘤样本分析显示病理完全缓解率或微小残留病灶率为39.5%。中位随访时间为22.3个月(存活者:36.8个月),所有意向性治疗人群(n = 107)的2年和3年总生存率分别为55%和40%(中位生存期 = 26.7个月),71例接受手术切除患者的2年和3年总生存率分别为62%和51%(中位生存期 = 36.5个月),36例未接受手术切除患者的2年和3年总生存率分别为41%和16%(中位生存期 = 19.1个月)。多因素分析显示,手术切除和肿瘤坏死>50%(或病理完全缓解)是死亡风险最相关的预测因素(风险比分别为0.50和0.48,p值分别为0.006和0.038)。
诱导放化疗后手术可行,尤其对于PS 0 - 1、IIB期(潘科斯特氏综合征)/III期NSCLC患者行肺叶切除术,但全肺切除术术后死亡风险高(特别是右全肺切除术)。诱导放化疗的病理缓解率在39.5%的患者中达到完全缓解,是总生存的重要预测因素。