Lin Chi-Miao, Yang Chiang-Hsing, Sung Fung-Chang, Li Chung-Yi
Department of Health Care Management, National Taipei College of Nursing, #89, Neichiang St., Taipei 10842, Taiwan.
Health Serv Res. 2008 Apr;43(2):675-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2007.00776.x.
To assess the causes and cause-specific risks of hospitalization among physicians in Taiwan.
The data used in this study were retrieved from filed claims and registries of the National Health Insurance Research Database. A cohort of 33,380 physicians contracted with the national insurance program between 1997 and 2002 were linked to the information on the inpatient claim data for hospitalization.
The physicians' incidence density of hospitalization was compared with that of the general population, other health personnel, and nurses to compute the calendar year-, age-, and gender-standardized hospitalization ratios (SHRs). A multivariate log-linear model was also used to assess the effects of gender, age, type of contract, and specialty on the risks of hospitalization.
Compared with the general population, physicians experienced significantly reduced risks of all causes (SHR=54.5, 95 percent confidence interval [CI] 53.4-55.5) and all major cause-specific hospitalizations, especially mental disorders (SHR=6.9, 95 percent CI 5.8-8.4). On the other hand, compared with other health personnel, physicians had a small but significantly higher risk of all causes of hospitalization (SHR=107.8, 95 percent CI 105.1-110.6). Higher risks of hospitalization were also noted for neoplasms (SHR=108.9, 95 percent CI 102.0-116.3) and diseases of the respiratory system (SHR=114.2, 95 percent CI 107.3-121.5). In addition to the above diagnoses, physicians also had significantly higher risks for genitourinary and musculoskeletal system and connective tissue problems than nurses. Compared with their physician colleagues, female physicians, young (<30 years) and older (> or =60 years) physicians, and those working with the health institutions and programs were at elevated risks of hospitalization for all causes as well as for certain specific diseases.
Physicians in Taiwan are at higher risks of developing specific diseases compared with their allied health colleagues. As the health of physicians is vital to the quality of care, Taiwanese health policy analysts should recognize that increased patient volume and satisfaction with public health care should not be achieved at the expense of physicians' health.
评估台湾地区医师住院的原因及特定病因风险。
本研究使用的数据取自国民健康保险研究数据库的存档理赔记录和登记信息。1997年至2002年期间与国家保险计划签约的33380名医师队列与住院患者理赔数据信息相关联。
将医师的住院发病密度与普通人群、其他卫生人员及护士的进行比较,以计算历年、年龄和性别标准化住院率(SHR)。还使用多变量对数线性模型评估性别、年龄、合同类型和专业对住院风险的影响。
与普通人群相比,医师所有病因(SHR = 54.5,95%置信区间[CI] 53.4 - 55.5)及所有主要特定病因住院的风险显著降低,尤其是精神障碍(SHR = 6.9,95% CI 5.8 - 8.4)。另一方面,与其他卫生人员相比,医师所有病因住院的风险虽小但显著更高(SHR = 107.8,95% CI 105.1 - 110.6)。肿瘤(SHR = 108.9,95% CI 102.0 - 116.3)和呼吸系统疾病(SHR = 114.2,95% CI 107.3 - 121.5)的住院风险也更高。除上述诊断外,医师泌尿生殖系统、肌肉骨骼系统及结缔组织问题的风险也显著高于护士。与医师同事相比,女性医师、年轻(<30岁)及年长(≥60岁)医师,以及在卫生机构和项目工作的医师,所有病因及某些特定疾病的住院风险均有所升高。
与相关卫生同行相比,台湾地区医师患特定疾病的风险更高。由于医师的健康对医疗质量至关重要,台湾地区卫生政策分析人士应认识到,不应以牺牲医师健康为代价来增加患者数量和提高公众对医疗保健的满意度。