De Luca Assunta, Gabriele Stefania, Lauria Laura, Francia Carlo, Caminiti Alessandro, Tubaro Marco, Pillon Sergio, Pristipino Christian, Ammirati Fabrizio, Guasticchi Gabriella
Area Governo dell'Offerta Lazio Sanità, Agenzia di Sanità Pubblica della Regione Lazio, Roma.
G Ital Cardiol (Rome). 2008 Feb;9(2):118-25.
Timely reperfusion therapies (primary angioplasty and pre-hospital thrombolysis) remain a key component in improving the survival of patients with ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI). The Lazio Region emergency organization has a complex mixed logistic (the large city of Rome, presence of complex orography), therefore the use of telemedicine technologies by the emergency medical system (EMS) is mandatory. Emergency clinical pathways (ECP) for the management of STEMI patients were designed, focusing on early pre-hospital diagnosis and best appropriate treatment through the ECG transmission and teleconsultation among EMS and cardiologists in coronary care units (CCU).
To evaluate the effectiveness of ECP-STEMI in the current practice, a prospective observational cohort study of ambulance-transported patients with cardiovascular symptoms was conducted in a selected area of the Lazio Region during a 6-month period. The implementation of the ECP was carried out by educational activities for the EMS personnel based on the "experiential learning" methods.
From October 2005 to March 2006, 287 patients were enrolled in the study and a pre-hospital ECG was performed in 66% of them. One hundred and fifty-two patients were referred to hospital and only 34 had discharged diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction, of whom 23 were STEMI. In the 34 acute myocardial infarction patients the medium time from "call to the EMS" to "arrival to the hospital" was 41 min (range 29-63 min) and 3 had their ECG telematically transmitted from the ambulance to the CCU. All of these cases were STEMI. Twenty-eight acute myocardial infarctions were discharged alive, 2 were transferred in other hospitals, 4 died. No patients received pre-hospital thrombolysis. Prior to the ECP implementation the ECG for STEMI patients has never been transmitted by EMS to the CCU in the Lazio Region.
Our study suggests that adherence to ECP improved the appropriateness of STEMI patient referral and treatment in the CCU in the Lazio Region. The EMS personnel, during the study, showed a high interest in the protocol trying to change their current practice. The Regional Administration plans to expand the utilization of ECP to all regional emergency network (EMS and Emergency Departments) and to improve its use.
及时的再灌注治疗(直接血管成形术和院前溶栓)仍然是提高ST段抬高型心肌梗死(STEMI)患者生存率的关键组成部分。拉齐奥地区的急救组织拥有复杂的混合后勤体系(罗马这座大城市,地形复杂),因此紧急医疗系统(EMS)必须使用远程医疗技术。设计了用于管理STEMI患者的紧急临床路径(ECP),重点是通过心电图传输以及EMS与冠心病监护病房(CCU)的心脏病专家之间的远程会诊实现早期院前诊断和最合适的治疗。
为了评估ECP-STEMI在当前实践中的有效性,在拉齐奥地区的一个选定区域进行了为期6个月的对救护车运送的有心血管症状患者的前瞻性观察队列研究。ECP的实施通过基于“体验式学习”方法对EMS人员开展教育活动来进行。
2005年10月至2006年3月,287例患者纳入研究,其中66%进行了院前心电图检查。152例患者被送往医院,只有34例出院诊断为急性心肌梗死,其中23例为STEMI。在这34例急性心肌梗死患者中,从“呼叫EMS”到“到达医院”的平均时间为41分钟(范围29 - 63分钟),3例患者的心电图通过远程方式从救护车传输到CCU。所有这些病例均为STEMI。28例急性心肌梗死患者存活出院,2例转至其他医院,4例死亡。没有患者接受院前溶栓治疗。在ECP实施之前,拉齐奥地区STEMI患者的心电图从未由EMS传输到CCU。
我们的研究表明,遵循ECP提高了拉齐奥地区STEMI患者转诊至CCU以及在CCU接受治疗的合理性。在研究期间,EMS人员对该方案表现出浓厚兴趣,并试图改变他们当前的做法。地区行政部门计划将ECP的使用扩展到所有地区紧急网络(EMS和急诊科)并改进其应用。