McEwen M R, Kawrakow I, Ross C K
Ionizing Radiation Standards, Institute for National Measurement Standards, National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0R6 Canada.
Med Phys. 2008 Mar;35(3):950-8. doi: 10.1118/1.2839329.
A precision experimental investigation of the effective point of measurement (EPOM) of ion chambers in megavoltage beams has been carried out. A one-dimensional scanning phantom system was developed with an overall accuracy in the positioning of a chamber of better than 0.15 mm. Depth-dose data were acquired for a 25 MV beam from an Elekta Precise linac (field sizes of 10 x 10 cm and 25 x 25 cm) for measurement depths in the range 0.6-6 cm. The results confirmed the Monte Carlo calculations of an earlier theoretical investigation by Kawrakow [Med. Phys. 33, 1829-1839 (2006)] that the standard shift for cylindrical chambers, recommended in dosimetry protocols of -0.6r (where r is the internal radius of the cavity), is incorrect. A wide range of ion chambers were investigated and it was found that errors of up to 1.4 mm could occur for certain chamber designs (although typical errors for common chambers were around 0.5 mm). A comparison between measurements and Monte Carlo simulations showed that once the correct EPOM is used, the details of the linac geometry are correct, and the parameters of the electron beam striking the bremsstrahlung target have been adequately determined, the EGSnrc Monte Carlo package is capable of reproducing the experimental data to 0.2 mm or better. The investigation also confirmed that for the highest accuracy depth-dose curves in megavoltage photon beams one should use a well-guarded parallel-plate ion chamber. Three chamber designs were tested here and found to be satisfactory-the Scanditronix-Wellhöfer NACP-02, PTW Roos and Exradin All.
对兆伏级射束中电离室的有效测量点(EPOM)进行了精确的实验研究。开发了一种一维扫描体模系统,电离室定位的总体精度优于0.15毫米。从Elekta Precise直线加速器获取了25 MV射束的深度剂量数据(射野尺寸为10×10 cm和25×25 cm),测量深度范围为0.6 - 6 cm。结果证实了Kawrakow [《医学物理》33, 1829 - 1839 (2006)]早期理论研究的蒙特卡罗计算结果,即剂量学协议中推荐的圆柱形电离室标准偏移量-0.6r(其中r是腔体内半径)是不正确的。研究了多种电离室,发现某些电离室设计可能会出现高达1.4毫米的误差(尽管常见电离室的典型误差约为0.5毫米)。测量结果与蒙特卡罗模拟的比较表明,一旦使用正确的EPOM,直线加速器几何结构细节正确,并且撞击轫致辐射靶的电子束参数已得到充分确定,EGSnrc蒙特卡罗软件包能够将实验数据重现到0.2毫米或更高精度。该研究还证实,对于兆伏级光子束中最高精度的深度剂量曲线,应使用精心防护的平行板电离室。这里测试了三种电离室设计,发现它们令人满意——Scanditronix-Wellhöfer NACP-02、PTW Roos和Exradin All。