Jobanputra Paresh, Amarasena Roshan, Maggs Fiona, Homer Dawn, Bowman Simon, Rankin Elizabeth, Filer Andrew, Raza Karim, Jubb Ronald
Department of Rheumatology, Selly Oak Hospital, University Hospital Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, Raddlebarn Road, Birmingham, B29 6JD, UK.
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2008 Apr 11;9:48. doi: 10.1186/1471-2474-9-48.
Spontaneous reporting systems for adverse drug reactions (ADRs) are handicapped by under-reporting and limited detail on individual cases. We report an investigation from a local surveillance for serious adverse drug reactions associated with disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs that was triggered by the occurrence of liver failure in two of our patients.
Serious ADR reports have been solicited from local clinicians by regular postcards over the past seven years. Patients', who had hepatotoxicity on sulfasalazine and met a definition of a serious ADR, were identified. Two clinicians reviewed structured case reports and assessed causality by consensus and by using a causality assessment instrument. The likely frequency of hepatotoxicity with sulfasalazine was estimated by making a series of conservative assumptions.
Ten cases were identified: eight occurred during surveillance. Eight patients were hospitalised, two in hepatic failure - one died after a liver transplant. All but one event occurred within 6 weeks of treatment. Seven patients had a skin rash, three eosinophilia and one interstitial nephritis. Five patients were of Black British of African or Caribbean descent. Liver enzymes showed a hepatocellular pattern in four cases and a mixed pattern in six. Drug-related hepatotoxicity was judged probable or highly probable in 8 patients. The likely frequency of serious hepatotoxicity with sulfasalazine was estimated at 0.4% of treated patients.
Serious hepatotoxicity associated with sulfasalazine appears to be under-appreciated and intensive monitoring and vigilance in the first 6 weeks of treatment is especially important.
药物不良反应(ADR)的自发报告系统存在报告不足以及个体病例细节有限的问题。我们报告了一项针对与改善病情抗风湿药相关的严重药物不良反应的本地监测调查,该调查由我们两名患者出现肝衰竭引发。
在过去七年中,通过定期明信片向当地临床医生征集严重ADR报告。识别出在柳氮磺吡啶治疗期间出现肝毒性且符合严重ADR定义的患者。两名临床医生审查结构化病例报告,并通过共识以及使用因果关系评估工具来评估因果关系。通过做出一系列保守假设来估计柳氮磺吡啶导致肝毒性的可能频率。
共识别出10例病例:8例在监测期间出现。8名患者住院,2例出现肝衰竭,其中1例在肝移植后死亡。除1例事件外,所有事件均发生在治疗后6周内。7例患者出现皮疹,3例出现嗜酸性粒细胞增多,1例出现间质性肾炎。5例患者为非洲或加勒比裔英国黑人。4例患者的肝酶表现为肝细胞型,6例为混合型。8例患者的药物相关肝毒性被判定为可能或极有可能。估计柳氮磺吡啶导致严重肝毒性的频率为治疗患者的0.4%。
与柳氮磺吡啶相关的严重肝毒性似乎未得到充分认识,在治疗的前6周进行强化监测和警惕尤为重要。