Owens Ann Marie, Johal Ama
Department of Orthodontics, Queen Mary's Institute of Dentistry, London, UK.
Angle Orthod. 2008 May;78(3):475-81. doi: 10.2319/040107-161.1.
To test the hypothesis that there is no difference between the actual mesiodistal root angulation and the mesiodistal root angulation as measured on the panoramic radiograph.
A typodont dentition was set up into a Class I occlusion. Wire struts were placed on the buccal surface of each tooth to represent their long axes. The dentition was fixed into a natural skull for imaging. The radiographic and true mesiodistal angulation of each tooth to a horizontal reference plane (the arch wire) was measured using a coordinate measuring machine (CMM). The mesiodistal root positions were then altered to a more mesial and then more distal position and the measurements were repeated.
Only 26.7% of the radiographic root angulations were within the clinically acceptable angular variation range of +/-2.5 degrees . The greatest variation in the upper arch occurred in the canine-premolar area where the roots were projected as being more divergent. The greatest variation in the lower arch occurred in the lateral incisor-canine region where these roots were projected as being more convergent. The extent of radiographic distortion is statistically greater in the lower arch than in the upper arch in the ideal (P < or = .05) and distal (P < or = .01) root positions.
The hypothesis is rejected. There is a clinically significant variation between the radiographic and the true root angulations recorded. Caution is advised when interpreting mesiodistal root angulation using this radiograph.
检验关于实际近远中牙根角度与全景X线片上所测量的近远中牙根角度之间不存在差异的假设。
将一副模型牙列排列成I类咬合关系。在每颗牙齿的颊面放置金属丝支柱以代表其长轴。将该牙列固定于天然颅骨上进行成像。使用坐标测量仪(CMM)测量每颗牙齿相对于水平参考平面(弓丝)的X线片和真实近远中角度。然后将近远中牙根位置改变为更靠近近中的位置,接着再改变为更靠近远中的位置,并重复测量。
仅26.7%的X线片牙根角度在临床上可接受的±2.5度角度变化范围内。上颌弓最大的变化发生在尖牙-前磨牙区域,该区域的牙根在X线片上显示为更分散。下颌弓最大的变化发生在侧切牙-尖牙区域,该区域的牙根在X线片上显示为更聚拢。在理想(P≤0.05)和远中(P≤0.01)牙根位置,下颌弓X线片失真程度在统计学上大于上颌弓。
该假设被拒绝。所记录的X线片牙根角度与真实牙根角度之间存在临床上显著的差异。使用该X线片解释近远中牙根角度时需谨慎。