Hagemann Rudolf
Acta Hist Leopoldina. 2007(48):113-58.
At the beginning, the two fundamental papers by Watson and Crick published in 1953 are presented. Subsequently, the main phases of protein and nucleic acids research, starting in the middle of the 19th century, are shortly reviewed. It is outlined, how the 'protein-paradigm' was gradually developed and ultimately became widely accepted. It is then described how Caspersson in 1936 newly raised the question what the chemical nature of genes was: proteins or nucleic acids ? In the main part of this report six lines of research are reviewed, the results of which led to the demise of the 'protein paradigm', the creation of the Watson-Crick model of the DNA and the elaboration of the mechanism of DNA replication: (a) mutation experiments with UV and determination of the UV action spectrum, (b) determination of the chemical identity of the transforming agent in bacteria, (c) detailed chemical analysis of the DNA of different organisms, (d) molecular investigation of the infection of bacteria by bacteriophages, (e) X-ray analysis of DNA fibers, (f) model building and theoretical treatment of all data obtained. In this article, the factors promoting and inhibiting scientific progress in this field are described (and, above all, the relations between scientists with fixated concepts). The results from these lines of research led to the recognition of the decisive role of nucleic acids as the carriers of genetic information and, in this way, formally established the 'nucleic acid paradigm'. Finally the question is discussed why Watson and Crick found the right solution for the DNA structure (and not one of their competitors).
文章开篇介绍了1953年沃森和克里克发表的两篇具有奠基意义的论文。随后,简要回顾了始于19世纪中叶的蛋白质和核酸研究的主要阶段。概述了“蛋白质范式”是如何逐渐发展并最终被广泛接受的。接着描述了1936年卡斯佩尔森如何重新提出基因的化学本质是什么的问题:是蛋白质还是核酸?在本报告的主要部分,回顾了六条研究路线,其结果导致了“蛋白质范式”的衰落、DNA沃森 - 克里克模型的建立以及DNA复制机制的阐述:(a)紫外线诱变实验及紫外线作用光谱的测定,(b)细菌中转化因子化学特性的测定,(c)不同生物体DNA的详细化学分析,(d)噬菌体感染细菌的分子研究,(e)DNA纤维的X射线分析,(f)对所有获得的数据进行模型构建和理论处理。在本文中,描述了该领域促进和抑制科学进步的因素(尤其是那些持有固定观念的科学家之间的关系)。这些研究路线的结果导致人们认识到核酸作为遗传信息载体的决定性作用,并由此正式确立了“核酸范式”。最后讨论了为什么沃森和克里克找到了DNA结构的正确解决方案(而不是他们的竞争对手之一)。