Department of Surgery, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Enugu, Nigeria.
Dev World Bioeth. 2009 Dec;9(3):138-48. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-8847.2008.00234.x. Epub 2008 Apr 29.
Most writing on informed consent in Africa highlights different cultural and social attributes that influence informed consent practices, especially in research settings. This review presents a composite picture of informed consent in Nigeria using empirical studies and legal and regulatory prescriptions, as well as clinical experience. It shows that Nigeria, like most other nations in Africa, is a mixture of sociocultural entities, and, notwithstanding the multitude of factors affecting it, informed consent is evolving along a purely Western model. Empirical studies show that 70-95% of Nigerian patients report giving consent for their surgical treatments. Regulatory prescriptions and adjudicated cases in Nigeria follow the Western model of informed consent. However, adversarial legal proceedings, for a multiplicity of reasons, do not play significant roles in enforcing good medical practice in Nigeria. Gender prejudices are evident, but not a norm. Individual autonomy is recognized even when decisions are made within the family. Consent practices are influenced by the level of education, extended family system, urbanization, religious practices, and health care financing options available. All limitations notwithstanding, consent discussions improved with increasing level of education of the patients, suggesting that improved physician's knowledge and increasing awareness and education of patients can override other influences. Nigerian medical schools should restructure their teaching of medical ethics to improve the knowledge and practices of physicians. More research is needed on the preferences of the Nigerian people regarding informed consent so as to adequately train physicians and positively influence physicians' behaviors.
大多数关于非洲知情同意的文献都强调了不同的文化和社会属性,这些属性会影响知情同意的实践,尤其是在研究环境中。本文使用实证研究、法律和法规规定以及临床经验,呈现了尼日利亚知情同意的综合情况。结果表明,尼日利亚与非洲的大多数国家一样,是各种社会文化实体的混合体,尽管有许多因素影响,但知情同意正在沿着纯粹的西方模式发展。实证研究表明,70-95%的尼日利亚患者报告同意接受他们的手术治疗。尼日利亚的法规规定和裁决案例遵循西方模式的知情同意。然而,由于多种原因,对抗性的法律程序在尼日利亚并没有在执行良好的医疗实践中发挥重要作用。性别偏见很明显,但不是常态。即使是在家庭内部做出决定,个人自主权也得到承认。同意实践受到教育程度、大家庭系统、城市化、宗教实践和医疗保健融资选择的影响。尽管存在所有限制,但随着患者教育水平的提高,同意讨论有所改善,这表明提高医生的知识水平以及提高患者的意识和教育水平可以克服其他影响。尼日利亚的医学院应该调整他们的医学伦理学教学,以提高医生的知识和实践水平。需要对尼日利亚人民对知情同意的偏好进行更多的研究,以便对医生进行充分的培训并对医生的行为产生积极影响。