Aweis Ahmed, Mauma Machunde, Aweis Abdulkadir, Afrah Abdulkadir, Guled Ibraahim Abdullahi, Kulane Asli
Department of Public Health, Capital University, Mogadishu, Somalia.
Department of Global Public Health, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Front Glob Womens Health. 2025 Aug 26;6:1584113. doi: 10.3389/fgwh.2025.1584113. eCollection 2025.
Informed consent is a crucial legal and ethical requirement in the physician-patient relationship for all aspects of care. Despite, patients have the right to make their own decision in health, women in the Middle East and Africa, including Somalia, often have limited autonomy in healthcare decisions due to patriarchal structures. In Somalia, male family members including husbands frequently hold the ultimate authority in women's healthcare choices, sometimes restricting access to lifesaving sexual and reproductive health services.
To explore doctors' experiences of delay or refusal to provide consent for lifesaving interventions for pregnant women in Somalia.
an exploratory, qualitative design. Purposive sampling was used to select doctors working in maternity wards in the five selected hospitals. A total of 22 medical doctors were interviewed using a semi structured interview guide, and the data were analyzed using thematic analysis.
An overarching theme emerged: "The disconnect between healthcare system and patriarchy system" with five sub-themes namely: (1) Consent is given only by paternal male family members (2) Paternal and male witnesses signatures required for the consent form (3) Paternal male conflicts and other reasons for delaying or refusing consent (4) Potential consequences for the doctors without the consent of paternal male (5) Changing the consent guidelines from paternal male dependency. Consent of the pregnant women is given by paternal male family members since they are responsible for her life (blood/) according to cultural practices. The husband's consent is sufficient only in the case of post-abortion care, as this also involves the fetus. Misconceptions that cesarean sections can damage the uterus, limit future pregnancies, or impair a woman's ability to perform daily activities also contribute to delayed or refusal of consent.
This study revealed that doctors require protection when performing their duties. All doctors who participated in the study were ready to save the lives of their patients, but were assured of their safety. Patients seem to cooperate with doctors, but the cultural practices of providing consent from male members remain a challenge to the intervention. A national health policy should be drafted and approved by the cabinet that grant women the sole right to consent to life-saving medical interventions. Additionally, community mobilization is needed to educate community leaders about the negative impact of delaying or denying women informed consent to essential healthcare due to the patriarchal norms.
知情同意是医患关系中医疗各方面至关重要的法律和伦理要求。尽管患者有权自主做出健康决策,但中东和非洲地区的女性,包括索马里女性,由于父权结构,在医疗决策方面往往自主权有限。在索马里,包括丈夫在内的男性家庭成员在女性医疗选择方面常常拥有最终决定权,有时会限制她们获得挽救生命的性健康和生殖健康服务。
探讨索马里医生在为孕妇提供挽救生命的干预措施时遇到的延迟或拒绝给予同意的经历。
采用探索性定性设计。目的抽样法用于选择在五家选定医院产科病房工作的医生。使用半结构化访谈指南对22名医生进行访谈,并采用主题分析法对数据进行分析。
出现了一个总体主题:“医疗系统与父权制系统之间的脱节”,有五个子主题,即:(1)仅由男性父系家庭成员给予同意;(2)同意书需要男性父系见证人的签名;(3)男性父系冲突及其他延迟或拒绝同意的原因;(4)未经男性父系同意对医生的潜在后果;(5)改变对男性父系依赖的同意指南。根据文化习俗,孕妇由男性父系家庭成员给予同意,因为他们对其生命(血统)负责。只有在堕胎后护理的情况下,丈夫的同意才足够,因为这也涉及胎儿。剖宫产会损害子宫、限制未来怀孕或损害女性日常活动能力的误解也导致同意延迟或被拒绝。
本研究表明,医生在履行职责时需要保护。所有参与研究的医生都愿意挽救患者生命,但需要确保他们的安全。患者似乎愿意与医生合作,但男性成员提供同意的文化习俗仍然是干预的一个挑战。应起草并由内阁批准一项国家卫生政策,赋予女性对挽救生命的医疗干预措施给予同意的唯一权利。此外,需要进行社区动员,以教育社区领袖了解由于父权规范而延迟或拒绝给予女性基本医疗知情同意的负面影响。