Mennemeier Mark, Chelette Kenneth C, Myhill Jeffery, Taylor-Cooke Patricia, Bartel Twyla, Triggs William, Kimbrell Timothy, Dornhoffer John
Department of Neurobiology and Developmental Science, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, Arkansas 72205, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2008 Jul;118(7):1228-32. doi: 10.1097/MLG.0b013e318170f8ac.
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: A single patient was tested to examine the safety and feasibility of using maintenance sessions of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (1 Hz rTMS) to reduce tinnitus loudness and prevent its return over time.
Interrupted time series with multiple replications.
Tinnitus loudness was assessed using a visual analogue rating (VAR) with 0 = no tinnitus, and 100 = loudest tinnitus experienced; 1,800 TMS pulses delivered at 1 Hz and 110% of motor threshold were administered over the posterior, superior lateral temporal gyrus of the subject's right hemisphere until subjective tinnitus fell to a VAR of 25. TMS was reapplied as tinnitus returned to a VAR of 25 or higher. Cerebral metabolism was measured using positron emission tomography before and after treatment.
In this patient, tinnitus could be reduced to a VAR of 6 or lower each time it reoccurred using one to three maintenance sessions of rTMS. Tinnitus loudness remained at or below a VAR of 25 and was reported to be unobtrusive in daily life when last assessed 4 months after the third and final round of maintenance treatment. Asymmetric increased cerebral metabolism in the right hemisphere reduced following treatment and as tinnitus improved. Maintenance treatment was well tolerated with no side effects.
Although a case study cannot establish treatment efficacy, this study demonstrates for the first time that it is feasible to use maintenance rTMS to manage chronic tinnitus. Maintenance rTMS might impede cortical expansion of the tinnitus frequency into adjacent cortical areas, but group studies are necessary to confirm this speculation.
目的/假设:对一名患者进行测试,以检验使用低频重复经颅磁刺激(1赫兹重复经颅磁刺激)维持治疗来降低耳鸣响度并防止其随时间复发的安全性和可行性。
多次重复的中断时间序列。
使用视觉模拟评分(VAR)评估耳鸣响度,0表示无耳鸣,100表示经历过的最响耳鸣;以1赫兹和运动阈值的110%给予1800个经颅磁刺激脉冲,作用于受试者右半球颞上回后部和外侧上部,直至主观耳鸣降至VAR为25。当耳鸣恢复到VAR为25或更高时,重新施加经颅磁刺激。在治疗前后使用正电子发射断层扫描测量脑代谢。
在该患者中,每次耳鸣复发时,使用一至三次重复经颅磁刺激维持治疗可将耳鸣响度降至VAR为6或更低。耳鸣响度保持在VAR为25或以下,在第三次也是最后一轮维持治疗后4个月进行最后一次评估时,据报告在日常生活中不明显。治疗后以及耳鸣改善后,右半球不对称性脑代谢增加减少。维持治疗耐受性良好,无副作用。
尽管案例研究不能确定治疗效果,但本研究首次证明使用重复经颅磁刺激维持治疗来管理慢性耳鸣是可行的。重复经颅磁刺激维持治疗可能会阻止耳鸣频率在皮质向相邻皮质区域扩展,但需要进行群体研究来证实这一推测。