Duijm Lucien E M, Groenewoud Johanna H, Fracheboud Jacques, Plaisier Menno L, Roumen Rudi M H, van Ineveld B Martin, van Beek Mike, de Koning Harry J
Department of Radiology, Catharina Hospital, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Eur Radiol. 2008 Nov;18(11):2390-7. doi: 10.1007/s00330-008-1043-5. Epub 2008 May 20.
We prospectively assessed trends in utilization and costs of diagnostic services of screen-positive women in a biennial breast cancer screening program for women aged 50-75 years. All 2,062 women with suspicious findings at screening mammography in the southern region of the Netherlands between 1 January 2000 and 1 July 2005 (158,997 screens) were included. Data were collected on any diagnostic examinations, interventional procedures, and surgical consultations with two-year follow-up. We used national reimbursement rates to estimate imaging costs and percutaneous biopsy costs. Cost prices, charged by hospitals, were used to estimate open surgical biopsy costs and surgical consultation costs. The largest increase in utilization of diagnostic procedures per 100 referrals was observed for axillary ultrasound (from 3.9 in 2000 to 33.5 in 2005) and for stereotactic core biopsy (from 2.1 in 2000 to 26.8 in 2005). Per 100 referrals, the open surgical biopsy rate decreased from 34.7 (2000) to 4.6 (2005) and the number of outpatient surgical consultations fluctuated between 269.8 (2000) and 309.7 (2004). Mean costs for the diagnosis of one cancer were Euro1,501 and ranged from Euro1,223 (2002) to Euro1,647 (2003). Surgical biopsies comprised 54.1% of total diagnostic costs for women screened in 2000, but decreased to 9.9% for women screened in 2005. Imaging costs increased from 23.7 to 43.8%, percutaneous biopsy costs from 9.9 to 27.2%, and consultation costs from 12.3 to 19.1%. We conclude that diagnostic costs per screen-detected cancer remained fairly stable through the years, although huge changes in the use of different diagnostic procedures were observed.
我们前瞻性地评估了一项针对50至75岁女性的两年一次乳腺癌筛查项目中,筛查结果呈阳性女性的诊断服务利用率和成本趋势。纳入了2000年1月1日至2005年7月1日期间荷兰南部地区在乳腺钼靶筛查中发现可疑结果的所有2062名女性(共158,997次筛查)。收集了有关任何诊断检查、介入程序以及为期两年随访的外科会诊的数据。我们使用国家报销率来估算影像检查成本和经皮活检成本。医院收取的成本价格用于估算开放式手术活检成本和外科会诊成本。每100例转诊中,诊断程序利用率增幅最大的是腋窝超声检查(从2000年的3.9次增至2005年的33.5次)和立体定向核心活检(从2000年的2.1次增至2005年的26.8次)。每100例转诊中,开放式手术活检率从2000年的34.7%降至2005年的4.6%,门诊外科会诊次数在269.8次(2000年)至309.7次(2004年)之间波动。诊断一例癌症的平均成本为1501欧元,范围从2002年的1223欧元至2003年的1647欧元。2000年接受筛查女性的外科活检占总诊断成本的54.1%,但在2005年接受筛查的女性中降至9.9%。影像检查成本从23.7%增至43.8%,经皮活检成本从9.9%增至27.2%,会诊成本从12.3%增至19.1%。我们得出结论,尽管不同诊断程序的使用情况发生了巨大变化,但多年来每例筛查出的癌症的诊断成本保持相对稳定。