Si-jia Gao, Meng-wei Zhang, Xi-ping Liu, Yu-shen Zhu, Jing-hong Liu, Zhong-hui Wang, Pei-zhuo Zang, Qiang Shi, Qiang Wang, Chuan-sheng Liang, Ke Xu
Department of Radiology, No. 1 Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang 110001, China.
Eur J Radiol. 2009 Jul;71(1):22-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2008.04.005. Epub 2008 May 21.
To explore the value of CT spinal angiography with 64-detector row spiral CT in diagnosing spinal vascular malformations.
Seventeen patients with initial MR and clinical findings suggestive of spinal vascular diseases underwent CT spinal angiography. Among these, 14 patients took DSA examination within 1 week after CT scan, 7 patients underwent surgical treatment, and 6 patients underwent vascular intervention embolotheraphy. CT protocol: TOSHIBA Aquilion 64 Slice CT scanner, 0.5mm thickness, 0.5s/r, 120 kV and 350 mA, positioned at the aortic arch level, and applied with "sure start" technique with CT threshold of 180 Hu. Contrast agent Iohexol (370 mg I/ml) was injected at 6 ml/s velocity with total volume of 80 ml. The post-processing procedures included MPR, CPR, MIP, VR, etc. Among the 17 patients, four patients underwent fast dynamic contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography imaging. CT spinal angiography and three-dimensional contrast-enhanced MR angiography (3D CE-MRA) images were compared and evaluated with DSA and operation results based on disease type, lesion range, feeding arteries, fistulas, draining veins of vascular malformation by three experienced neuroradiologists independently, using double blind method. The data were analyzed using SPSS analytic software with chi(2)-test. We compared the results with DSA and operation results.
The statistical analysis of the diagnostic results by the three experienced neuroradiologists had no statistical difference (P>0.05). All of the 17 patients showed clearly the abnormality of spinal cord vessels and the range of lesions by CT spinal angiography. Among them, one patient was diagnosed as arteriovenous fistulas (AVF) by MRI and CT spinal angiography, which was verified by surgical operation. DSA of the same patient, however, did not visualize the lesion. One case was diagnosed as AVM complicated with AVF by DSA, but CT spinal angiography could only show AVM not AVF. The type differentiations of all the other 16 patients were consistent with DSA results. For 13 cases with positive CT spinal angiography results, DSA displayed 20 feeding vessels, among which 16 vessels were displayed correctly by CT spinal angiography, four could not be visualized, and two turned out to be false-positive. Fistulas were not displayed in six cases by CT spinal angiography. Draining veins were displayed clearly in all cases, which agreed with DSA results. Four cases who took CE-MRA obtained the same type diagnosis as that from CT spinal angiography. Feeding arteries were not displayed in CE-MRA of one case, but could be clearly visualized in other three cases, and the results agreed with CTA and DSA results. Fistulas could be seen in two cases. Draining veins and the disease range could be displayed distinctly by 3D CE-MRA.
CT spinal angiography is quite valuable for diagnosing vascular malformation of spinal cord. It can be a screening exam before DSA, and has a guiding effect on DSA, reducing the amount of time required for DSA.
探讨64排螺旋CT脊髓血管造影在诊断脊髓血管畸形中的价值。
17例初诊磁共振成像(MR)及临床表现提示脊髓血管疾病的患者接受了CT脊髓血管造影检查。其中,14例患者在CT扫描后1周内接受了数字减影血管造影(DSA)检查,7例患者接受了手术治疗,6例患者接受了血管介入栓塞治疗。CT扫描方案:采用东芝Aquilion 64排CT扫描仪,层厚0.5mm,转速0.5s/r,管电压120kV,管电流350mA,扫描范围自主动脉弓水平开始,采用“sure start”技术,CT阈值设定为180Hu。以6ml/s的流速注射碘海醇(370mg I/ml)造影剂,总量80ml。后处理方法包括多平面重组(MPR)、曲面重组(CPR)、最大密度投影(MIP)、容积再现(VR)等。17例患者中,4例接受了快速动态对比增强三维MR血管造影成像。由3名经验丰富的神经放射科医师采用双盲法,根据疾病类型、病变范围、供血动脉、瘘口、血管畸形的引流静脉,对CT脊髓血管造影和三维对比增强MR血管造影(3D CE-MRA)图像与DSA及手术结果进行比较和评估。采用SPSS分析软件进行χ²检验分析数据。将结果与DSA及手术结果进行比较。
3名经验丰富的神经放射科医师对诊断结果的统计分析无统计学差异(P>0.05)。17例患者均通过CT脊髓血管造影清晰显示脊髓血管异常及病变范围。其中1例患者MRI及CT脊髓血管造影诊断为动静脉瘘(AVF),手术证实。然而,该患者的DSA未显示病变。1例患者DSA诊断为动静脉畸形(AVM)合并AVF,但CT脊髓血管造影仅显示AVM而未显示AVF。其余16例患者的类型鉴别与DSA结果一致。CT脊髓血管造影结果阳性的13例患者中,DSA显示20条供血血管,其中16条血管CT脊髓血管造影正确显示,4条未显示,2条为假阳性。CT脊髓血管造影6例未显示瘘口。所有病例引流静脉均显示清晰,与DSA结果一致。4例接受CE-MRA检查的患者诊断类型与CT脊髓血管造影相同。1例患者CE-MRA未显示供血动脉,但其他3例显示清晰,结果与CTA及DSA结果一致。2例可见瘘口。3D CE-MRA可清晰显示引流静脉及病变范围。
CT脊髓血管造影对诊断脊髓血管畸形具有重要价值。它可作为DSA前的筛查检查,对DSA有指导作用,减少DSA所需时间。