Melby Carolyn S, Dodgson Joan E, Tarrant Marie
National College of Nursing, Tokyo, Japan.
J Nurs Scholarsh. 2008;40(2):176-83. doi: 10.1111/j.1547-5069.2008.00223.x.
To describe the lived experience of English-speaking Western nurse educators teaching in East Asian countries.
The study design was an application of existential phenomenological approach to qualitative data collection and analysis. Eight expatriate nurse educators who had taught more than 2 years in an East Asian country were interviewed about their experiences between January 2004 and November 2005.
Narrative data were analyzed using a phenomenological approach aimed at distilling the experience of the educators. Each member of the research team analyzed the data, then through group discussions a consensus was reached, paying close attention to developing clear understandings of language nuances and maintaining the participants' voices.
Four themes emerged from the data: (a) differing expectations, (b) the cost of the expatriate experience, (c) bridging pedagogies, and (d) adapting and finding purpose. The tacit meanings of cultural differences affecting participants' experiences are presented.
The ways that a collectivist-oriented culture may affect nurse educators coming from a Western individualist worldview needs to continue to be researched to develop better mutual understandings that will lead to culturally collaborative models of nursing practice, education and research.
Nurses providing direct care and nurse educators who work with people from cultures other than their own will find the discussion of cross-cultural misunderstandings useful.
描述在东亚国家教学的英语为母语的西方护士教育工作者的实际经历。
本研究设计采用存在主义现象学方法进行定性数据收集与分析。2004年1月至2005年11月期间,对8位在东亚国家任教超过2年的外籍护士教育工作者进行了关于他们经历的访谈。
采用现象学方法分析叙事数据,旨在提炼教育工作者的经历。研究团队的每位成员都对数据进行了分析,然后通过小组讨论达成共识,密切关注对语言细微差别的清晰理解并保留参与者的观点。
数据中出现了四个主题:(a)不同的期望,(b)外籍经历的代价,(c)教学方法的衔接,以及(d)适应并找到目标。呈现了影响参与者经历的文化差异的隐含意义。
集体主义文化可能影响来自西方个人主义世界观的护士教育工作者的方式,仍需继续研究,以增进相互理解,从而形成护理实践、教育和研究的文化协作模式。
提供直接护理的护士以及与来自不同文化背景的人合作的护士教育工作者会发现跨文化误解的讨论很有用。