Forsberg Hans, Sjödin Lars, Lundgren Per, Wänman Anders
Department of Strategic Management, County Council of Västerbotten, Umeå, Sweden.
Swed Dent J. 2008;32(1):17-25.
The objective of this study was to analyse the possibilities and limitations of using data drawn from electronic dental patient records (EDPRs) in monitoring dental health among adults in a northern Swedish county.
The study population comprised all 35-, 50-, 65- and 75-year-old patients who were examined and, where required, received treatment at the Public Dental Service (PDS) in Västerbotten, Sweden, in 2003 and in 2004. In total 2,497 patients in 2003, and 2,546 patients in 2004 met the inclusion criteria. As controls, 779 subjects randomly drawn from the adult population in the same age groups and from the same county were used. They participated in an oral health survey and were examined clinically between October 2002 and March 2003.
When oral health was estimated based on EDPRs the prevalence of edentulous subjects was significantly underestimated, while the mean numbers of teeth and the mean values of sound teeth were significantly overestimated. No statistically significant difference was found in prevalence of primary decayed tooth surfaces (DS). The prevalence of filled teeth (FT) was fairly similar between the study samples. Registrations of periodontal status were mainly missing in the EDPRs. Since registrations related to temporomandibular disorders are not included in the T4 system its prevalence could not be assessed and accordingly not compared with the epidemiological sample.
The study shows that clinical registration based on EDPRs is at present not accurate enough to be used as indicators of oral health status among adults in a community.
本研究的目的是分析利用电子牙科患者记录(EDPRs)中的数据监测瑞典北部一个县成年人牙齿健康状况的可能性和局限性。
研究人群包括2003年和2004年在瑞典韦斯特博滕公共牙科服务机构(PDS)接受检查并在需要时接受治疗的所有35岁、50岁、65岁和75岁患者。2003年共有2497名患者,2004年有2546名患者符合纳入标准。作为对照,使用了从同一年龄组和同一县的成年人群中随机抽取的779名受试者。他们参加了口腔健康调查,并于2002年10月至2003年3月期间接受了临床检查。
根据EDPRs评估口腔健康时,无牙患者的患病率被显著低估,而平均牙齿数和健全牙齿的平均值被显著高估。原发性龋坏牙面(DS)的患病率没有统计学上的显著差异。研究样本中补牙(FT)的患病率相当相似。EDPRs中主要缺少牙周状况的记录。由于与颞下颌关节紊乱相关的记录未包含在T4系统中,因此无法评估其患病率,也无法与流行病学样本进行比较。
该研究表明,基于EDPRs的临床记录目前不够准确,不能用作社区中成年人口腔健康状况的指标。