De Backer Hein, Van Maele Georges, De Moor Nathalie, Van den Berghe Linda
Centre for Special Care, PaeCaMed Research, Unit of Gnathology and Temporomandibular Disorders, Dental School, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ghent University, Belgium.
Int J Prosthodont. 2008 May-Jun;21(3):259-66.
This study evaluated treatment outcomes of 4-unit porcelain-fused-to-gold fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) replacing 2 adjacent missing teeth.
A total of 102 FDPs made in an undergraduate university clinic for 73 patients were evaluated for up to 20 years, with a mean survival follow-up time of 11.4 years. All patients were offered an oral health maintenance program. Treatment failures were divided into irreversible (loss of FDPs/finish line involved) or reversible (FDPs and finish line intact after conservative treatment) complications and into biologic and technical/patient-related failures.
The Kaplan-Meier overall estimated survival rate was 68.3% at year 20. There was a statistically significant difference (P = .007) between the survival rates in the maxilla for the vital group (73.8%) and those for the root canal-treated group (25.1%). Comparing the survival rate in the root canal-treated group for the restorations in the maxilla (25.1%) versus the mandible (66.8%), a statistically significant difference (P = .011) was found. The main reason for irreversible failure was caries (32.0%).
The estimated successful outcome of 4-unit FDPs over an up to 20-year period is considered favorable and should be compared with the survival rates of other treatment options for the replacement of 2 adjacent teeth. Occurrence of a previously reversible complication appears to be a predictive factor for an irreversible complication later on. A reversible complication within the first 2 years will lead to an early irreversible complication.
本研究评估了用于替代两颗相邻缺失牙的4单位烤瓷熔附金属固定义齿(FDPs)的治疗效果。
对一所大学本科诊所为73例患者制作的共102个FDPs进行了长达20年的评估,平均生存随访时间为11.4年。所有患者均接受了口腔健康维护计划。治疗失败分为不可逆(FDPs丧失/涉及边缘线)或可逆(保守治疗后FDPs和边缘线完整)并发症,以及生物学和技术/患者相关失败。
20年时,Kaplan-Meier总体估计生存率为68.3%。活髓组上颌的生存率(73.8%)与根管治疗组上颌的生存率(25.1%)之间存在统计学显著差异(P = .007)。比较根管治疗组上颌修复体(25.1%)与下颌修复体(66.8%)的生存率,发现存在统计学显著差异(P = .011)。不可逆失败的主要原因是龋齿(32.0%)。
4单位FDPs长达20年的估计成功结果被认为是良好的,应与替代两颗相邻牙齿的其他治疗选择的生存率进行比较。先前可逆并发症的发生似乎是后来不可逆并发症的预测因素。前两年内出现的可逆并发症将导致早期不可逆并发症。