De Backer Hein, Van Maele Georges, Decock Veerle, Van den Berghe Linda
Centre for Special Care, PaeCaMed Research, Unit of Gnathology and Temporomandibular Disorders, Dental School, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ghent University, Belgium.
Int J Prosthodont. 2007 May-Jun;20(3):229-34.
This study investigated the long-term survival of posts and cores on root canal-treated (RCT) teeth restored with complete crowns, fixed dental prostheses (FDPs), 3-unit FDPs, and cantilever FDPs (C-FDPs) made over a period of 16 to 20 years in an undergraduate clinic.
Complete treatment and follow-up records of 1,037 complete crowns, 134 three-unit FDPs, 322 FDPs, and 168 C-FDPs were available for analysis. All RCT teeth studied had a post-and-core buildup. Kaplan-Meier survival curves were used to evaluate the different types of fixed restorations.
For complete crowns, the estimated survival rates at year 18 were 74.9% for the vital group and 79.4% for the RCT group (P = .602). For 3-unit FDPs, the survival rate at year 20 was 83.2% for the vital group and 60.5% for the RCT group (P = .108). For the FDPs, the survival rate at year 20 was 77.4% for the vital group, while for the RCT group with at least 1 RCT abutment, the survival rate was 56.7% (P = .002). For C-FDPs with vital abutments, the survival rate was 73.5% at year 16, while for the RCT group with at least 1 RCT abutment, the survival rate was 52.3% at year 18 (P < .01).
There was no statistically significant difference in the long-term survival of complete crowns on vital abutments versus post-and-core complete crowns or in the survival of 3-unit FDPs on vital abutments versus those with at least 1 RCT abutment. For FDPs with more than 3 units and C-FDPs, the use of a post-and-core abutment led to significantly more failures.
本研究调查了在本科诊所制作的全冠、固定义齿(FDP)、3单位FDP和悬臂固定义齿(C-FDP)修复的根管治疗(RCT)牙齿上桩核的长期存活率,这些修复体制作时间为16至20年。
有1037个全冠、134个3单位FDP、322个FDP和168个C-FDP的完整治疗及随访记录可供分析。所有研究的RCT牙齿均进行了桩核修复。采用Kaplan-Meier生存曲线评估不同类型的固定修复体。
对于全冠,活髓组在第18年的估计存活率为74.9%,RCT组为79.4%(P = 0.602)。对于3单位FDP,活髓组在第20年的存活率为83.2%,RCT组为60.5%(P = 0.108)。对于FDP,活髓组在第20年的存活率为77.4%,而对于至少有1个RCT基牙的RCT组,存活率为56.7%(P = 0.002)。对于有活髓基牙的C-FDP,在第16年的存活率为73.5%,而对于至少有1个RCT基牙的RCT组,在第18年的存活率为52.3%(P < 0.01)。
活髓基牙上的全冠与桩核全冠的长期存活率或活髓基牙上的3单位FDP与至少有1个RCT基牙的FDP的存活率之间无统计学显著差异。对于超过3单位的FDP和C-FDP,使用桩核基牙导致的失败显著更多。