Buchheim M A, Chapman R L
Department of Botany, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge 70803-1705.
Biosystems. 1991;25(1-2):85-100. doi: 10.1016/0303-2647(91)90015-d.
A study of phylogenetic relationships of the colonial green algal flagellates based on nuclear 18S and 26S rRNA sequence data suggests that the colonial habit has had at least two independent origins. All colonial taxa included in the analysis, except Stephanosphaera, are allied in a clade with Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and other Chlamydomonas taxa ascribed to the Euchlamydomonas group by Ettl. In contrast, Stephanosphaera is allied with other unicellular flagellates including Haematococcus. Comparison of the 18S and 26S data shows that the two sets of data yield different results following cladistic analysis. The 18S data provide the principal signal that supports the more basal divergences, but the data do not unambiguously address relationships among taxa in the clade that includes most colonial flagellates and Chlamydomonas taxa representative of the Euchlamydomonas group (sensu Ettl). In contrast, the 26S data have fewer informative sites that support basal divergences than the 18S data, but provide much of the signal that supports resolution of taxa in the colonial flagellate clade in an analysis of the combined 18S and 26S rRNA sequence data. Additional sequence data from the 26S molecule and additional taxa may reduce the topological ambiguity inferred from the sequence data for the colonial flagellates. Alternatively, an ancient and rapid radiation of taxa in the colonial lineage could account for the topological ambiguity. Despite some unresolved questions of relationships, cladistic analysis of the combined data sets provides some robustly supported concepts of evolution in these flagellates.
一项基于核18S和26S rRNA序列数据对群体绿藻鞭毛虫系统发育关系的研究表明,群体习性至少有两个独立的起源。分析中纳入的所有群体分类单元,除了Stephanosphaera外,都与莱茵衣藻以及Ettl归为真衣藻组的其他衣藻分类单元归为一个进化枝。相比之下,Stephanosphaera与包括血球藻在内的其他单细胞鞭毛虫归为一类。18S和26S数据的比较表明,在进行分支系统分析后,这两组数据产生了不同的结果。18S数据提供了支持更基础分歧的主要信号,但这些数据并未明确解决包括大多数群体鞭毛虫和代表真衣藻组(按照Ettl的定义)的衣藻分类单元在内的进化枝中各分类单元之间的关系。相比之下,26S数据中支持基础分歧的信息位点比18S数据少,但在对18S和26S rRNA序列数据进行联合分析时,提供了许多支持群体鞭毛虫进化枝中各分类单元解析的信号。来自26S分子的更多序列数据和更多分类单元可能会减少从群体鞭毛虫序列数据推断出的拓扑歧义。或者,群体谱系中分类单元的古老且快速的辐射可能解释了拓扑歧义。尽管存在一些未解决的关系问题,但对合并数据集进行的分支系统分析为这些鞭毛虫的进化提供了一些得到有力支持的概念。