Giles E, Hutchinson D L
Department of Anthropology, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.
J Forensic Sci. 1991 May;36(3):765-80.
The use of reported stature, especially self-reported stature such as on a driver's license, as a proxy for measured stature is necessary when measured stature is unavailable, for example, in matching data calculated from skeletal remains with data for missing persons. The accuracy of self-reported stature for older persons and especially for tall and short people is not well ascertained. Examination of published reports provides evidence that beginning at age 45, people compound their stature overestimation by an additional amount related to age (women by twice the amount of men). Analysis of anthropometric data from 8000 U.S. Army personnel indicates that the amount of general overestimation of stature by men is 2 1/2 times greater than that by women. Neither tall men nor tall women underestimate their stature, but men in the upper third of the stature range, and women in the upper 10%, self-report their stature with greater accuracy. No trends in accuracy are apparent in the remainder of the stature spectrum for men or women.
当无法获得测量身高时,例如在将骨骼遗骸计算的数据与失踪人员数据进行匹配时,使用报告身高,尤其是如驾照上的自我报告身高来替代测量身高是必要的。老年人,尤其是高个子和矮个子人群自我报告身高的准确性尚未得到很好的确定。对已发表报告的审查表明,从45岁开始,人们会因年龄因素(女性的高估幅度是男性的两倍)而进一步高估自己的身高。对8000名美国陆军人员的人体测量数据分析表明,男性对身高的总体高估幅度是女性的2.5倍。高个子男性和高个子女性都不会低估自己的身高,但身高处于前三分之一范围的男性以及身高处于前10%的女性,自我报告身高时的准确性更高。在男性或女性身高范围的其余部分,准确性没有明显趋势。