White Katherine J Curtis
Department of Rural Sociology, 350 Agricultural Hall, 1450 Linden Drive, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI 53706, USA.
Demography. 2008 May;45(2):363-86. doi: 10.1353/dem.0.0010.
I investigate the relationship between county population change and farm dependence in the Great Plains region during the twentieth century, using spatial data analysis techniques. This research is rooted in a long-standing sociological and demographic interest in population responses to economic transitions and informs the theoretical understanding of urbanization processes. Using census and environmental data, the analysis challenges earlier assertions of a simple transition in the relationship between farm dependence and population change that accompanied modern technological advancements, namely tractors (the mechanization thesis). Rather than observing the proposed positive-to-negative shift, study results show a negative association throughout the pre- and post-mechanization periods. Partial support is found if the thesis is revised to consider the relationship between population change and the change in farm dependence rather than the level of farm dependence. Findings show mixed support for an alternative argument that nonfarm industries moderate the influence of farm dependence (the industry complex thesis). In contrast to earlier applications of the thesis, industrial relations in the Great Plains context are characterized by specialization rather than cooperation.
我运用空间数据分析技术,研究了20世纪大平原地区县域人口变化与农业依赖之间的关系。这项研究源于社会学和人口统计学长期以来对人口对经济转型反应的关注,并为城市化进程的理论理解提供了依据。利用人口普查和环境数据,该分析对早期关于随着现代技术进步(即拖拉机的出现,机械化论点),农业依赖与人口变化之间关系发生简单转变的论断提出了挑战。研究结果并未观察到所提出的从正向负的转变,而是显示在机械化前后时期都存在负相关。如果将该论点修订为考虑人口变化与农业依赖变化之间的关系而非农业依赖水平,能找到部分支持。研究结果对非农业产业缓和农业依赖影响这一替代论点(产业复合体论点)的支持程度不一。与该论点早期的应用不同,大平原地区背景下的产业关系以专业化而非合作的特点。