Rupprecht H J, Brennecke R, Erbel R, Kerz T, Bernhard G, Meyer J
II. Medizinische Klinik, Johannes-Gutenberg-Universität, Mainz.
Z Kardiol. 1991 Apr;80(4):286-9.
We evaluated a 3-year clinical follow-up in 53 patients with unsuccessful PTCA, due to failure to reach the lesion (control-group) in comparison to a "matched pairs" group of 53 patients, in whom PTCA had been performed (PTCA-group). There were no deaths in the PTCA-group compared to 3 deaths (5.7%) in the control-group (ns). Two patients (3.8%) and three patients (5.7%), respectively, suffered an acute transmural myocardial infarction during the follow-up period (ns). Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) had been performed in five patients (9.4%) following PTCA, and in 17 patients (32.1%) of the control-group (p less than 0.002). The overall rate of serious cardiac events (death, myocardial infarction or CABG) amounted to 13.2% (seven patients) in the PTCA-group and to 43.4% (23 patients) in the control-group (p less than 0.002). Only in the PTCA-group was a repeat PTCA performed in 15 patients (28.3%) with restenosis (p less than 0.00003). 35 of 53 patients in the PTCA-group (66%) and 27 of 50 survivors in the control-group were free of symptoms at the end of follow-up (ns). These results demonstrate that PTCA in patients with single-vessel disease is followed by a marked reduction of serious cardiac events, predominantly of bypass-operations, but the necessity of a second PTCA-procedure in case of restenosis has to be considered.
我们对53例因未能到达病变部位而PTCA失败的患者(对照组)进行了为期3年的临床随访,并与53例接受了PTCA的患者(PTCA组)进行“配对”比较。PTCA组无死亡病例,而对照组有3例死亡(5.7%)(无显著性差异)。随访期间,PTCA组和对照组分别有2例患者(3.8%)和3例患者(5.7%)发生急性透壁性心肌梗死(无显著性差异)。PTCA后,PTCA组有5例患者(9.4%)接受了冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG),而对照组有17例患者(32.1%)接受了CABG(p<0.002)。PTCA组严重心脏事件(死亡、心肌梗死或CABG)的总发生率为13.2%(7例患者),对照组为43.4%(23例患者)(p<0.002)。仅在PTCA组,15例发生再狭窄的患者(28.3%)接受了再次PTCA(p<0.00003)。随访结束时,PTCA组53例患者中有35例(66%)无症状,对照组50例幸存者中有27例无症状(无显著性差异)。这些结果表明,单支血管病变患者接受PTCA后,严重心脏事件,主要是旁路手术,显著减少,但再狭窄时需要考虑进行第二次PTCA手术。