Kammes K L, Heemink G B H, Albrecht K A, Combs D K
Department of Dairy Science, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA.
J Dairy Sci. 2008 Aug;91(8):3138-44. doi: 10.3168/jds.2007-0865.
The mixture of kura clover (Trifolium ambiguum M. Bieb.) and reed canarygrass (Phalaris arundinacea L.) has proven to be extremely persistent in the northern United States, but information about dairy cow performance on this mixture is lacking. Twenty lactating Holstein cows were used in a crossover design to compare dry matter (DM) intake and milk production from diets containing kura clover-reed canarygrass silage (KRS) or alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) silage (AS). Forages were cut, wilted, ensiled in horizontal plastic bags, and allowed to ferment for at least 50 d before beginning the feeding experiment. The KRS was approximately 40% kura clover and 60% reed canarygrass. Treatments were total mixed rations formulated with either 57% of total DM from 1) AS or 2) KRS. Experimental periods were 28 d, with the first 14 d for diet adaptation and the last 14 d for measurement of intake and milk production. The neutral detergent fiber (NDF) concentrations of AS and KRS were 37.3 and 47.3%, respectively. The fermentation analyses indicated that both silages underwent a restricted fermentation, producing primarily lactic acid and some acetic acid. Dry matter intake (24.2 vs. 22.8 kg) and 4% fat-corrected milk (32.8 vs. 30.9 kg) were significantly higher for cows fed AS than for cows fed KRS. Cows consumed less NDF (6.7 vs. 8.0 kg) and less digestible NDF (3.0 vs. 4.4 kg) when fed AS diets compared with KRS diets, but the pool of ruminally undegraded NDF was similar (3.7 kg) between diets. Cows produced 1.5 kg of milk/kg of DM consumed regardless of the diet, indicating that digestible NDF of KRS was utilized with similar efficiency as the cell wall constituents of AS, but the intake of cows fed KRS may have been limited by rumen fill. Milk fat concentration tended to be higher for cows fed AS, but the milk true protein concentration and yields of fat and protein did not differ by treatment. Milk urea nitrogen content was higher when cows consumed AS (16.4 mg/ dL) compared with KRS (13.4 mg/dL). The cows fed KRS consumed more NDF but less total DMI, based on the results from this trial with diets formulated to contain approximately 60% of DM as forage, resulting in slightly lower milk yields than cows fed excellent-quality AS. This grass-legume mixture has the potential to be a source of quality forage for dairy cows in regions where alfalfa persistence is a problem.
库拉三叶草(Trifolium ambiguum M. Bieb.)和芦苇状金丝雀草(Phalaris arundinacea L.)的混合物在美国北部已被证明具有极强的持久性,但缺乏关于奶牛在这种混合物上生产性能的信息。采用交叉设计,使用20头泌乳期荷斯坦奶牛,比较含库拉三叶草 - 芦苇状金丝雀草青贮饲料(KRS)或苜蓿(Medicago sativa L.)青贮饲料(AS)日粮的干物质(DM)摄入量和产奶量。将牧草收割、萎蔫后,装入卧式塑料袋青贮,并在开始饲喂试验前至少发酵50天。KRS约含40%的库拉三叶草和60%的芦苇状金丝雀草。处理组为全混合日粮,分别由1)AS或2)KRS提供57%的总干物质。试验期为28天,前14天用于日粮适应,后14天用于测量摄入量和产奶量。AS和KRS的中性洗涤纤维(NDF)浓度分别为37.3%和47.3%。发酵分析表明,两种青贮饲料均经历了有限的发酵,主要产生乳酸和一些乙酸。饲喂AS的奶牛干物质摄入量(24.2对22.8千克)和4%乳脂校正乳产量(32.8对30.9千克)显著高于饲喂KRS的奶牛。与KRS日粮相比,饲喂AS日粮的奶牛消耗的NDF较少(6.7对8.0千克)和可消化NDF较少(3.0对4.4千克),但日粮间瘤胃未降解NDF的量相似(3.7千克)。无论日粮如何,奶牛每消耗1千克DM产奶1.5千克,这表明KRS的可消化NDF与AS的细胞壁成分利用效率相似,但饲喂KRS的奶牛摄入量可能受到瘤胃充盈的限制。饲喂AS的奶牛乳脂浓度往往较高,但乳真蛋白浓度以及脂肪和蛋白质产量在处理间无差异。奶牛消耗AS时乳尿素氮含量较高(16.4毫克/分升),而消耗KRS时较低(13.4毫克/分升)。基于本试验中以约60% DM为牧草配制的日粮结果,饲喂KRS的奶牛消耗更多的NDF,但总干物质采食量较少,导致产奶量略低于饲喂优质AS的奶牛。在苜蓿持久性存在问题的地区,这种禾本科 - 豆科混合物有可能成为奶牛优质牧草的来源。