Desailly Eric, Daniel Yepremian, Sardain Philippe, Lacouture Patrick
Laboratoire de Mécanique des Solides, Université de Poitiers, UMR-6610, CNRS, SP2MI, BP-30179, 86962 Futuroscope Cedex, France.
Gait Posture. 2009 Jan;29(1):76-80. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2008.06.009. Epub 2008 Aug 3.
Initial contact (IC) and toe off (TO) times are essential measurements in the analysis of temporal gait parameters, especially in cerebral palsy (CP) gait analysis. A new gait event detection algorithm, called the high pass algorithm (HPA) has been developed and is discussed in this paper. Kinematics of markers on the heel and metatarsal are used. Their forward components are high pass filtered, to amplify the contact discontinuities, thus the local extrema of the processed signal correspond to IC and TO. The accuracy and precision of HPA are compared with the gold standard of foot contact event detection, that is, force plate measurements. Furthermore HPA is compared with two other kinematics methods. This study has been conducted on 20 CP children and on eight normal adults. For normal subjects all the methods performed equally well. True errors in HPA (mean+/-standard deviation) were found to be 1+/-23 ms for IC and 2+/-25 ms for TO in CP children. These results were significantly (p<0.05) more accurate and precise than those obtained using the other algorithms. Moreover, in the case of pathological gaits, the other methods are not suitable for IC detection when IC is flatfoot or forefoot. In conclusion, the HPA is a simple and robust algorithm, which performs equally well for adults and actually performs better when applied to the gait of CP children. It is therefore recommended as the method of choice.
初始接触(IC)时间和蹬离(TO)时间是分析步态时间参数时的重要测量指标,尤其是在脑瘫(CP)步态分析中。本文开发并讨论了一种名为高通算法(HPA)的新步态事件检测算法。该算法使用了足跟和跖骨上标记物的运动学数据。对其向前的分量进行高通滤波,以放大接触的不连续性,这样处理后信号的局部极值就对应于初始接触和蹬离。将HPA的准确性和精确性与足部接触事件检测的金标准(即测力台测量)进行比较。此外,还将HPA与其他两种运动学方法进行了比较。本研究对20名脑瘫儿童和8名正常成年人进行。对于正常受试者,所有方法的表现都一样好。在脑瘫儿童中,发现HPA的真实误差(均值±标准差)在初始接触时为1±23毫秒,在蹬离时为2±25毫秒。这些结果比使用其他算法获得的结果在准确性和精确性上都有显著提高(p<0.05)。此外,在病理性步态的情况下,当出现扁平足或前足着地的初始接触时,其他方法不适用于初始接触检测。总之,HPA是一种简单且稳健的算法,对成年人的表现同样良好,而应用于脑瘫儿童步态时实际表现更佳。因此,推荐将其作为首选方法。