[Cycle ergometer stress testing for identification of significant coronary artery disease: improved accuracy by the use of chronotropic reserve adjustment of ST-segment depression].

BACKGROUND

Diagnostic reliability of indexations of peak exercise ST-segment depression (deltaST) for heart rate reserve (HRi) or chronotropic reserve (CR) to identify significant coronary artery disease (CAD) by bicycle exercise testing has not been evaluated previously.

METHODS

Upright bicycle exercise testing (25 W increment every 3 min) was performed in consecutive patients in primary prevention with at least one of the following criteria: history of exercise-induced chest discomfort and cardiovascular risk factors; overt peripheral arterial disease; type 2 diabetes associated with two or more additional cardiovascular risk factors. Coronary angiography was performed to define significant CAD (stenosis > or = 70% of the main coronary arteries or of their major branches, or isolated left main stenosis > or = 50%, or two or more stenoses 50-69%). Duke angina index was used to grade exercise-induced chest pain; deltaST, ST/HRi and ST/CR were calculated at peak exercise; three different criteria for the definition of inducible myocardial ischemia were tested versus significant CAD: peak deltaST > or =100 microV, ST/HRi > 1.69 microV/b/min or ST/CR > 1.76 microV/%.

RESULTS

Of the study sample (n = 46), 40% had typical angina; during stress test 80% showed deltaST > or = 100 microV; 76% had ST/HRi > 1.69 microV/b/min; 62% had ST/CR >1.76 microV/%. Diagnostic accuracy of deltaST > or = 100 microV, of ST/HRi > 1.69 micro5V/b/min, and of ST/CR > 1.76 microV/% were 78%, 72%, and 89% respectively (p < 0.001 for the difference in diagnostic performance). ST/CR > 1.76 microV/% showed the highest diagnostic accuracy both in patients with submaximal exercise (96%) and in women (92%). Similarly, ST/CR >1.76 microV/% was associated with the highest diagnostic accuracy both in patients with maximal exercise (78%) and in men (88%). Analyses of the ROC curve revealed that ST/CR was associated with the greatest area under the curve, and a population-specific cut-off of 1.77 microV/% was associated with a sensitivity of 88% and a specificity of 90%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our pilot study suggests that in patients undergoing bicycle stress testing for differential diagnosis or screening of significant CAD, and with moderate-to-high pre-test probability, the use of ST/CR > 1.76 microV/% may provide elevated sensitivity and specificity, and the best diagnostic accuracy, which was consistent in patients with submaximal exercise test and in women.