Lee K Jane, Dupree Claretta Y
Department of Pediatrics, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201, USA.
J Palliat Med. 2008 Sep;11(7):986-90. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2007.0283.
The purposes of this study were to describe the experiences of pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) staff caring for a child who dies, and to determine whether responses included unprompted indications of moral distress as described in the literature. This qualitative, descriptive study consisted of semistructured interviews conducted with professional caregivers of a child who died in a large, multidisciplinary PICU. Interviews were audiotaped, transcribed and subjected to content analysis. Main results Interviews (n = 32) were conducted with 29 staff members regarding 8 patient deaths. Participants included nurses, physicians, and psychosocial support personnel. The overall tone of the interviews was positive, and participants expressed satisfaction with their work and the work of their colleagues. The major themes of staff members experiences were (1) importance of communication, (2) accommodating the wishes of others despite personal preferences, (3) ambiguity about the use of technology, (4) sadness, and (5) emotional support. Descriptions of moral distress were seen infrequently. Many welcomed the sadness they experienced as a sign of their humanity and emotional availability, but did not feel adequately supported in dealing with their grief.
The experience of caring for a child who dies in the PICU is multifaceted. Grief, rather than moral distress, was the dominant psychological response of caregivers. Future research could focus on enhancing communication and emotional support.
本研究的目的是描述儿科重症监护病房(PICU)工作人员照顾死亡儿童的经历,并确定这些反应是否包括文献中所述的未被提示的道德困扰迹象。这项定性描述性研究包括对在一家大型多学科PICU中死亡儿童的专业护理人员进行的半结构化访谈。访谈进行录音、转录并进行内容分析。主要结果 就8例患者死亡情况对29名工作人员进行了32次访谈。参与者包括护士、医生和心理社会支持人员。访谈的总体基调是积极的,参与者对自己的工作和同事的工作表示满意。工作人员经历的主要主题包括:(1)沟通的重要性;(2)尽管有个人偏好仍顺应他人的意愿;(3)技术使用方面存在的不确定性;(4)悲伤;(5)情感支持。很少见到关于道德困扰的描述。许多人欣然接受他们所经历的悲伤,认为这是他们有人性和情感丰富的表现,但在应对悲伤时觉得没有得到足够的支持。
在PICU照顾死亡儿童的经历是多方面的。悲伤而非道德困扰是护理人员主要的心理反应。未来的研究可以侧重于加强沟通和情感支持。