De Renzi E, Faglioni P, Grossi D, Nichelli P
Clinica Neurologica, Università di Modena.
Cortex. 1991 Jun;27(2):213-21. doi: 10.1016/s0010-9452(13)80125-6.
Three prosopagnosic patients were given four face tests, two perceptual (an unknown face identification test and an age estimation test) and two also implying memory (a familiarity check test and a famous face recognition test). The patients' performance was assessed with reference to the score distribution of the normal population. A patient was found to fail both perceptual and mnestic tests, without any noticeable difference between them. Also the second patient had poor scores on both kinds of tests, but his impairment was significantly greater on the perceptual ones. The third patient, on the contrary, showed no perceptual deficit and only failed the mnestic tests. His inability to recognize the individuality of an item among members of the same category was strictly confined to faces and never present for other classes of stimuli (cars, coins, personal belongings). This finding is supportive of the thesis that in a few patients the deficit underlying prosopagnosia is face specific.
三名面孔失认症患者接受了四项面部测试,两项是感知测试(一项未知面孔识别测试和一项年龄估计测试),另外两项也涉及记忆(一项熟悉度检查测试和一项名人面孔识别测试)。根据正常人群的分数分布对患者的表现进行评估。发现一名患者在感知测试和记忆测试中均未通过,两者之间没有明显差异。第二名患者在这两种测试中的得分也很低,但他在感知测试中的损伤明显更大。相反,第三名患者没有表现出感知缺陷,只是在记忆测试中未通过。他无法在同一类别的成员中识别出某个物品的个体特征,这种情况严格局限于面孔,在其他类别的刺激物(汽车、硬币、个人物品)中从未出现过。这一发现支持了这样一种观点,即在少数患者中,面孔失认症背后的缺陷是特定于面孔的。