Melnick W
Department of Otalaryngology, Ohio State University, Columbus 43210.
J Acoust Soc Am. 1991 Jul;90(1):147-54. doi: 10.1121/1.401308.
Information regarding the relation of human temporary threshold shift (TTS) to properties of steady-state and intermittent noise published since the 1966 appearance of the CHABA damage risk contours is reviewed. The review focuses on results from four investigative areas relevant to potential revision of the CHABA contours including effects of long-duration exposure and asymptotic threshold shifts (ATS); equivalent quiet and/or safe noise levels; effects of intermittency; and use of noise-induced temporary threshold shift (NITTS) to predict susceptibility to noise-induced permanent threshold shift (NIPTS). These data indicate that two of three major postulates on which the original contours were based are not valid. First, recovery from TTS is not independent of the conditions that produced the TTS as was assumed. Second, the assumption that all exposures that produce equal TTS2 are equally hazardous is not substantiated. The third postulate was that NIPTS produced by 10 years of daily exposure is approximately equal to the TTS2 produced by the same noise after an 8-h exposure. Based upon several TTS experiments showing that TTS reaches an asymptote after about 8 h of exposure, the third CHABA postulate can be reworded to state the hypothesis that ATS produced by sound of fixed level and spectrum represents an upper bound on PTS produced by that sound regardless of the exposure duration or the number of times exposed. This hypothesis has a strong, logical foundation if ATS represents a true asymptote for TTS, not a temporary plateau, and if threshold shifts do not increase after the noise exposure ceases.
自1966年CHABA损伤风险等值线出现以来,关于人类暂时性阈移(TTS)与稳态噪声和间歇性噪声特性之间关系的信息得到了综述。本综述聚焦于与CHABA等值线潜在修订相关的四个研究领域的结果,包括长时间暴露的影响和渐近阈移(ATS);等效安静和/或安全噪声水平;间歇性的影响;以及使用噪声诱发的暂时性阈移(NITTS)来预测对噪声诱发的永久性阈移(NIPTS)的易感性。这些数据表明,原始等值线所基于的三个主要假设中的两个是无效的。首先,TTS的恢复并不像所假设的那样独立于产生TTS的条件。其次,所有产生相等TTS2的暴露具有同等危险性这一假设没有得到证实。第三个假设是,10年每日暴露产生的NIPTS大约等于相同噪声在8小时暴露后产生的TTS2。基于几个TTS实验表明TTS在暴露约8小时后达到渐近线,CHABA的第三个假设可以重新表述为这样一个假设:固定水平和频谱的声音产生的ATS代表该声音产生的永久性阈移(PTS)的上限,而与暴露持续时间或暴露次数无关。如果ATS代表TTS的真正渐近线,而不是一个暂时的平稳期,并且如果在噪声暴露停止后阈移不会增加,那么这个假设有一个强有力的、合乎逻辑的基础。