Ramani Subha
Department of Medicine, Section of General Internal Medicine, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts 02118, USA.
Med Teach. 2008;30(9-10):851-6. doi: 10.1080/01421590802206747.
Physical examination (PEx) skills are declining among medical trainees, yet many institutions are not teaching these systematically and effectively. Many variables contribute to effective teaching: teachers' confidence in their clinical skills, ability to demonstrate and assess these skills; availability of suitable patients; trainee attitude and fatigue; belief that institutions do not value clinical teachers. Finally, the relevance and significance of a systematic exam must be demonstrated or the teaching degenerates into a 'show-and-tell' exercise.
This paper describes twelve practical teaching tips that can be used to promote high quality PEx teaching in 5 minutes or 45 minutes. TEACHING TIPS: (1) Diagnostic hypotheses should guide reflective exam; (2) Teachers with the best clinical skills should be recruited; (3) A longitudinal and systematic curriculum can tailor teaching to multiple learner levels (4) Integration of simulation and bedside teaching can maximise learning; (5) Bedside detective work and games make learning fun; (6) The 6-step approach to teach procedures can be adopted to teach PEx; (7) Clinical teaching at the bedside should be increased; (8) Linking basic sciences to clinical findings will demonstrate relevance; (9) Since assessment drives learning, clinical skills should be systematically assessed; (10) Staff development can target improvement of teachers' clinical skills for effective teaching; (11) Technology should be used to study utility of clinical signs; (12) Institutions should elevate the importance of clinical skills teaching and recognize and reward teachers.
PEx is important in patient-physician interactions, a valuable contributor to accurate clinical diagnosis and can be taught effectively using practical tips. To reverse the trend of deficient clinical skills, precision of clinical findings should be studied and exam manoeuvres that do not contribute to diagnosis discarded; institutions should value clinical skills teaching, appoint and fund core faculty to teach and provide staff development to improve teaching skills.
医学实习生的体格检查(PEx)技能正在下降,但许多机构并未系统且有效地教授这些技能。许多因素有助于有效教学:教师对其临床技能的信心、展示和评估这些技能的能力;合适患者的可及性;实习生的态度和疲劳程度;认为机构不重视临床教师的观念。最后,必须证明系统检查的相关性和重要性,否则教学就会沦为一场“展示与讲述”的活动。
本文描述了十二条实用教学小贴士,可用于在5分钟或45分钟内促进高质量的PEx教学。教学小贴士:(1)诊断假设应指导反思性检查;(2)应招募临床技能最佳的教师;(3)纵向和系统的课程可以根据多个学习者水平调整教学;(4)模拟教学与床边教学相结合可使学习效果最大化;(5)床边侦查工作和游戏使学习变得有趣;(6)可采用六步法教授操作程序来教授PEx;(7)应增加床边临床教学;(8)将基础科学与临床发现相联系将证明其相关性;(9)由于评估推动学习,应系统评估临床技能;(10)员工发展应以提高教师的临床技能以实现有效教学为目标;(11)应利用技术研究临床体征的效用;(12)机构应提升临床技能教学的重要性,认可并奖励教师。
PEx在医患互动中很重要,是准确临床诊断的重要贡献因素,并且可以通过实用小贴士进行有效教学。为扭转临床技能不足的趋势,应研究临床发现的精确性,摒弃那些无助于诊断的检查操作;机构应重视临床技能教学,任命并资助核心教师进行教学,并提供员工发展以提高教学技能。