Smith Kelly B, Pukall Caroline F
Department of Psychology, Queen's University, Kingston, 62 Arch Street, Ontario, Canada.
Psychooncology. 2009 May;18(5):465-75. doi: 10.1002/pon.1411.
To conduct an evidence-based review of yoga as an intervention for patients with cancer. Specifically, this paper reviewed the impact of yoga on psychological adjustment among cancer patients.
A systematic literature search was conducted between May 2007 and April 2008. Data from each identified study were extracted by two independent raters; studies were included if they assessed psychological functioning and focused on yoga as a main intervention. Using a quality rating scale (range = 9-45), the raters assessed the methodological quality of the studies, and CONSORT guidelines were used to assess randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Effect sizes were calculated when possible. In addition, each study was narratively reviewed with attention to outcome variables, the type of yoga intervention employed, and methodological strengths and limitations.
Ten studies were included, including six RCTs. Across studies, the majority of participants were women, and breast cancer was the most common diagnosis. Methodological quality ranged greatly across studies (range = 15.5-42), with the average rating (M = 33.55) indicating adequate quality. Studies also varied in terms of cancer populations and yoga interventions sampled.
This study provided a systematic evaluation of the yoga and cancer literature. Although some positive results were noted, variability across studies and methodological drawbacks limit the extent to which yoga can be deemed effective for managing cancer-related symptoms. However, further research in this area is certainly warranted. Future research should examine what components of yoga are most beneficial, and what types of patients receive the greatest benefit from yoga interventions.
对瑜伽作为癌症患者干预措施进行循证综述。具体而言,本文回顾了瑜伽对癌症患者心理调适的影响。
于2007年5月至2008年4月进行系统的文献检索。两名独立评分者提取每项纳入研究的数据;若研究评估心理功能且以瑜伽作为主要干预措施,则纳入该研究。评分者使用质量评分量表(范围=9 - 45)评估研究的方法学质量,并使用CONSORT指南评估随机对照试验(RCT)。尽可能计算效应量。此外,对每项研究进行叙述性综述,关注结果变量、所采用的瑜伽干预类型以及方法学的优势和局限性。
纳入10项研究,包括6项RCT。在各项研究中,大多数参与者为女性,最常见的诊断是乳腺癌。研究的方法学质量差异很大(范围=15.5 - 42),平均评分(M = 33.55)表明质量尚可。研究在癌症人群和所抽样的瑜伽干预方面也存在差异。
本研究对瑜伽与癌症的文献进行了系统评价。尽管注意到了一些积极结果,但研究之间的差异和方法学缺陷限制了瑜伽被认为对管理癌症相关症状有效的程度。然而,该领域的进一步研究当然是必要的。未来的研究应探讨瑜伽的哪些组成部分最有益,以及哪些类型的患者从瑜伽干预中获益最大。