Semmer A E, Lee M S, Harrison A R, Olsen T W
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
Br J Ophthalmol. 2008 Dec;92(12):1653-5. doi: 10.1136/bjo.2008.144402. Epub 2008 Oct 1.
To compare current hydroxychloroquine retinopathy screening practices with the published 2002 American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) Preferred Practice Patterns (PPP).
A multiple-choice survey was distributed to 105 ophthalmologists to assess current screening practices and knowledge of patient risk factors. Results were compared with the PPP guidelines. A cost analysis of the PPP and survey paradigms was conducted.
Sixty-seven (64%) of 105 surveys were completed. The majority (90%) of physicians screen for hydroxychloroquine retinopathy with either central automated threshold perimetry or Amsler grid as recommended by the PPP. Most survey respondents could not correctly identify the evidence-based risk factors. The majority screen more frequently than recommended: 87% screen high-risk patients and 94% screen low-risk patients more frequently than recommended in the PPP. The increased screening frequency of low-risk patients translates into an excess of $44 million in the first 5 years of therapy. If all patients were screened using exact PPP paradigm, savings could exceed $150 million every 10 years.
Ophthalmologists currently screen for hydroxychloroquine retinopathy correctly; however, their lack of familiarity with evidence-based guidelines may result in excessive follow-up. Increasing awareness and implementation of the PPP could potentially reduce hydroxychloroquine retinopathy screening costs significantly.
将当前羟氯喹视网膜病变筛查实践与2002年美国眼科学会(AAO)发布的《首选实践模式》(PPP)进行比较。
向105名眼科医生发放多项选择调查问卷,以评估当前的筛查实践及对患者风险因素的了解情况。将结果与PPP指南进行比较。对PPP和调查模式进行成本分析。
105份调查问卷中有67份(64%)完成。大多数(90%)医生按照PPP的建议,使用中心自动阈值视野检查或阿姆斯勒方格表来筛查羟氯喹视网膜病变。大多数调查对象无法正确识别循证风险因素。大多数人的筛查频率高于建议值:87%的人对高危患者的筛查频率高于PPP建议值,94%的人对低危患者的筛查频率高于PPP建议值。对低危患者增加的筛查频率在治疗的头5年导致超过4400万美元的额外费用。如果所有患者都按照精确的PPP模式进行筛查,每10年可节省超过1.5亿美元。
眼科医生目前对羟氯喹视网膜病变的筛查是正确的;然而,他们对循证指南的不熟悉可能导致过度随访。提高对PPP的认识并加以实施可能会显著降低羟氯喹视网膜病变的筛查成本。