Deans Jamie, Playle Rebecca, Durning Peter, Richmond Stephen
Department of Dental Health and Biological Sciences, Cardiff University Dental Hospital, Cardiff, UK.
Eur J Orthod. 2009 Feb;31(1):90-4. doi: 10.1093/ejo/cjn040. Epub 2008 Oct 14.
This study investigated the orthodontic treatment of 429 consecutive patients [172 male (40.1 per cent) and 257 female (59.9 per cent)] carried out by 10 orthodontic specialist practitioners in seven European countries [two in the Czech Republic (A and B), two in Germany (A and B), Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, and Netherlands, and two in Slovenia (A and B)]. The median age of the patients at the start of treatment was 13.0 years (minimum 7.3 years maximum 50.3 years). The patients had a range of malocclusions and the majority (97 per cent) were treated with upper and lower fixed appliances. Real exchange rates were calculated using purchasing power parity (PPP) indicators to allow cross-border comparisons of costs. The Index of Complexity, Outcome and Need (ICON) was used to measure the effectiveness of treatment and cost per ICON point reduction to compare cost-effectiveness of orthodontic treatment between practitioners in different European countries. The median cost per ICON point reduction for all the cases treated was 57.69 euro. The median cost per ICON point reduction varied greatly between practitioners from 21.70 euro (Lithuania) to 116.62 euro (Slovenia A). Analysis of variance and Tukey post hoc tests showed the differences in cost-effectiveness between the practitioners to be statistically significant (P<0.001). The cost per ICON point reduction is a simple and effective method of comparing cost-effectiveness between orthodontic practitioners in different countries.
本研究调查了由七个欧洲国家的10位正畸专科医生对429例连续患者[172例男性(40.1%)和257例女性(59.9%)]进行的正畸治疗。这七个欧洲国家分别是:捷克共和国的两家(A和B)、德国的两家(A和B)、意大利、拉脱维亚、立陶宛、荷兰以及斯洛文尼亚的两家(A和B)。治疗开始时患者的年龄中位数为13.0岁(最小7.3岁,最大50.3岁)。患者存在多种错牙合畸形,大多数(97%)接受了上下固定矫治器治疗。使用购买力平价(PPP)指标计算实际汇率,以便进行成本的跨境比较。采用复杂性、结果与需求指数(ICON)来衡量治疗效果,并通过每降低一个ICON点的成本来比较不同欧洲国家正畸医生的治疗成本效益。所有治疗病例每降低一个ICON点的成本中位数为57.69欧元。每降低一个ICON点的成本中位数在不同医生之间差异很大,从21.70欧元(立陶宛)到116.62欧元(斯洛文尼亚A)不等。方差分析和Tukey事后检验表明,不同医生之间的成本效益差异具有统计学意义(P<0.001)。每降低一个ICON点的成本是比较不同国家正畸医生成本效益的一种简单有效的方法。