Trutschnigg Barbara, Chong Chin, Habermayerova Lucia, Karelis Antony D, Komorowski Joanna
Department of Exercise Science, Concordia University, The Richard J. Renault Science Pavilion, Montreal, QC H4B1R6, Canada.
Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2008 Oct;33(5):863-9. doi: 10.1139/H08-071.
Low body fat mass and menstrual irregularities have been associated with low bone mineral density (BMD). The aim of this study was to compare the relation between BMD, lean body mass, fat mass, physical activity energy expenditure (PAEE), and menstrual status in female boxers and in physically active females with low (C1) or average (C2) fat mass. Boxers (n = 11) and controls (C1, n = 16; C2, n = 17), aged 18-38 years, were assessed for BMD and body composition with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. Menstrual status and PAEE were determined from questionnaires. There was no difference in anthropometric measurements between boxers and C1 subjects, except that boxers had higher arm lean mass. However, both boxers and C1 subjects had a lower percentage of fat (p < 0.001) than C2 subjects (boxers, 14.6% +/- 2.0; C1, 15.5% +/- 4.2; C2, 25.8% +/- 3.4%), and boxers had a higher (p = 0.002) lean body mass index (lean body mass/height2, where lean body mass is measured in kilograms and height is measured in metres) than C2 subjects. The PAEE of boxers was higher (p < 0.007) than that of controls (boxers, 5748 +/- 2284 ; C1, 2966 +/- 2258 ; C2, 2714 +/- 1722 kcal.week-1). Oligomenorrhea was more common in boxers than in C1 and C2 subjects (boxers, 54.6%; C1, 18.8%; C2, 35.3%). Arm, leg, and spine BMD were higher (p < 0.008) in boxers than in C1 subjects, and arm BMD was higher in boxers than in C2 subjects. BMD Z scores were also higher (p < 0.05) in boxers (boxers, 1.1+/- 0.8, C1, 0.1 +/- 0.7; C2: 0.3 +/- 1.1). High BMD in boxers, despite low fat mass, high PAEE, and an increased incidence of oligomenorrhea suggest that boxing has a positive effect on BMD.
低体脂量和月经不规律与低骨矿物质密度(BMD)有关。本研究的目的是比较女性拳击运动员以及低体脂量(C1组)或平均体脂量(C2组)的体力活动女性中,BMD、瘦体重、脂肪量、身体活动能量消耗(PAEE)和月经状况之间的关系。对11名年龄在18 - 38岁的拳击运动员以及16名C1组和17名C2组对照者进行双能X线吸收法评估BMD和身体成分。通过问卷确定月经状况和PAEE。拳击运动员与C1组受试者的人体测量学指标无差异,只是拳击运动员的手臂瘦体重较高。然而,拳击运动员和C1组受试者的脂肪百分比均低于C2组受试者(p < 0.001)(拳击运动员为14.6% ± 2.0;C1组为15.5% ± 4.2;C2组为25.8% ± 3.4%),且拳击运动员的瘦体重指数(瘦体重/身高²,瘦体重以千克为单位,身高以米为单位)高于C2组受试者(p = 0.002)。拳击运动员的PAEE高于对照组(p < 0.007)(拳击运动员为5748 ± 2284;C1组为2966 ± 2258;C2组为2714 ± 1722千卡·周⁻¹)。与C1组和C2组受试者相比,少经在拳击运动员中更常见(拳击运动员为54.6%;C1组为18.8%;C2组为35.3%)。拳击运动员手臂、腿部和脊柱的BMD高于C1组受试者(p < 0.008),且拳击运动员手臂的BMD高于C2组受试者。拳击运动员的BMD Z评分也更高(p < 0.05)(拳击运动员为1.1 ± 0.8,C1组为0.1 ± 0.7;C2组为0.3 ± 1.1)。尽管拳击运动员脂肪量低、PAEE高且少经发生率增加,但BMD高表明拳击对BMD有积极影响。