Prudent Max, Dramé Moustapha, Jolly Damien, Trenque Thierry, Parjoie Renaud, Mahmoudi Rachid, Lang Pierre-Olivier, Somme Dominique, Boyer François, Lanièce Isabelle, Gauvain Jean-Bernard, Blanchard François, Novella Jean-Luc
University of Reims Champagne-Ardenne, Faculty of Medicine, EA 3797, and Department of Clinical Gerontology, University Hospitals of Reims, Reims, France.
Drugs Aging. 2008;25(11):933-46. doi: 10.2165/0002512-200825110-00004.
In France, there is evidence to suggest that 50% of elderly individuals are prescribed psychotropic medications. However, it is known that use of these agents increases the risk of falls, fractures and delirium in older people.
To study the consumption of 'potentially inappropriate medication' (PIM) among patients aged>or=75 years, paying particular attention to psychotropic drugs and the factors influencing the use of 'potentially inappropriate psychotropics' (PIPs).
This was a cross-sectional analysis of a prospective multicentre cohort of 1306 hospitalized French patients aged>or=75 years (the SAFEs [Sujet Agé Fragile: Evaluation et suivi (Frail Elderly Subjects: Evaluation and follow-up)] cohort). The present analysis involved the 1176 patients for whom there was information on the usual treatments being taken in the 2 weeks before hospitalization. The drugs were coded according to the Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical classification; the Beers list as updated in 2003 defined which medications were considered PIPs. Standardized geriatric assessment variables were recorded on inclusion in the study. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify factors linked to use of psychotropics and PIPs.
The mean number of drugs taken was 5.7+/-2.9 per patient. Twenty-eight percent of patients took at least one PIM. The number of patients who had taken at least one psychotropic drug in the 2 weeks before hospitalization (mean 1.6+/-0.9 psychotropics per patient) was 589 (50.1%). More than half of both the 510 patients with a depressive syndrome and the 543 patients affected by dementia were treated with psychotropics. Multivariate analysis showed that prescription of psychotropics was linked to the presence of a dementia syndrome (odds ratio [OR]=1.4; 95% CI 1.1, 1.9; p=0.03), the presence of a depressive syndrome (OR=1.7; 95% CI 1.3, 2.1; p<0.001), living in an institution (OR=2.2; 95% CI 1.5, 3.4; p<0.001), use of more than five drugs (OR=3.2; 95% CI 2.5, 4.2; p<0.001) and Charlson's co-morbidity score>1 (OR=0.6; 95% CI 0.5, 0.8; p=0.001). Nineteen percent of all psychotropics prescribed were PIPs. Of these PIPs, 66.5% were anxiolytics, 28.4% were antidepressants and 5.1% were antipsychotics. Use of PIPs in the multivariate analysis was associated only with consumption of more than five drugs (OR=1.7; 95% CI 1.1, 2.5; p=0.01).
PIM use is common among hospitalized older adults in France. The most important determinant of risk of receiving a psychotropic medication or a PIP was the number of drugs being taken. The elderly, who have multiple co-morbidities, complex chronic conditions and are usually receiving polypharmacy, are at increased risk for adverse drug events. These adverse events are often linked to problems that could be preventable such as delirium, depression and falls. Regular review of prescriptions would help optimize prescription of psychotropics in the elderly. The Beers list is a good tool for evaluating PIMs but is too restrictive with respect to psychotropics; in the latter respect, the list could usefully be widened.
在法国,有证据表明50%的老年人被开具了精神类药物。然而,众所周知,使用这些药物会增加老年人跌倒、骨折和谵妄的风险。
研究75岁及以上患者中“潜在不适当用药”(PIM)的使用情况,尤其关注精神类药物以及影响“潜在不适当精神类药物”(PIP)使用的因素。
这是一项对1306名年龄≥75岁的法国住院患者的前瞻性多中心队列研究(SAFEs [Sujet Agé Fragile: Evaluation et suivi (Frail Elderly Subjects: Evaluation and follow-up)]队列)的横断面分析。本分析纳入了1176名患者,这些患者有住院前两周内常用治疗药物的信息。药物根据解剖治疗化学分类进行编码;2003年更新的Beers清单定义了哪些药物被视为PIP。在纳入研究时记录标准化的老年评估变量。进行逻辑回归分析以确定与精神类药物和PIP使用相关的因素。
每位患者服用药物的平均数为5.7±2.9种。28%的患者服用了至少一种PIM。在住院前两周内至少服用过一种精神类药物的患者人数为589人(50.1%)(每位患者平均服用1.6±0.9种精神类药物)。患有抑郁综合征的510名患者和患有痴呆症的543名患者中,超过一半的人接受了精神类药物治疗。多变量分析显示,精神类药物的处方与痴呆综合征的存在(比值比[OR]=1.4;95%置信区间1.1, 1.9;p=0.03)、抑郁综合征的存在(OR=1.7;95%置信区间1.3, 2.1;p<0.001)、住在养老院(OR=2.2;95%置信区间1.5, 3.4;p<0.001)、使用超过五种药物(OR=3.2;95%置信区间2.5, 4.2;p<0.001)以及Charlson共病评分>1(OR=0.6;95%置信区间0.5, 0.8;p=0.001)有关。所有开具的精神类药物中有19%是PIP。在这些PIP中,66.5%是抗焦虑药,28.4%是抗抑郁药,5.1%是抗精神病药。多变量分析中PIP的使用仅与使用超过五种药物有关(OR=1.7;95%置信区间1.1, 2.5;p=0.01)。
在法国,住院老年人中PIM的使用很常见。接受精神类药物或PIP风险的最重要决定因素是所服用药物的数量。患有多种合并症、复杂慢性病且通常接受多种药物治疗的老年人发生药物不良事件的风险增加。这些不良事件通常与谵妄、抑郁和跌倒等可预防的问题有关。定期审查处方将有助于优化老年人精神类药物的处方。Beers清单是评估PIM的一个好工具,但对精神类药物的限制过严;在这方面,该清单可适当放宽。