Witting Lars
Greenland Institute of Natural Resources, P. O. Box 570, DK-3900 Nuuk, Greenland.
Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc. 2008 Aug;83(3):259-94. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-185x.2008.00043.x.
Since neo-Darwinism arose from the work of Darwin and Mendel evolution by natural selection has been seen as contingent and historical being defined by an a posteriori selection process with no a priori laws that explain why evolution on Earth has taken the direction of the major evolutionary trends and transitions instead of any other direction. Recently, however, major life-history trends and transitions have been explained as inevitable because of a deterministic selection that unfolds from the energetic state of the organism and the density-dependent competitive interactions that arise from self-replication in limited environments. I describe differences and similarities between the historical and deterministic selection processes, illustrate concepts using life-history models on large body masses and limited reproductive rates, review life-history evolution with a wider focus on major evolutionary transitions, and propose that biotic evolution is driven by a universal natural selection where the long-term evolution of fitness-related traits is determined mainly by deterministic selection, while contingency is important predominately for neutral traits. Given suitable environmental conditions, it is shown that selection by energetic state and density-dependent competitive interactions unfolds to higher level selection for life-history transitions from simple asexually reproducing self-replicators to large bodied organisms with senescence and sexual reproduction between males and females, and in some cases, to the fully evolved eusocial colony with thousands of offspring workers. This defines an evolutionary arrow of time for open thermodynamic systems with a constant inflow of energy, predicting similar routes for long-term evolution on similar planets.
自从新达尔文主义源于达尔文和孟德尔的研究工作以来,自然选择导致的进化一直被视为偶然的和历史性的,它由一个后验选择过程定义,没有先验定律来解释为什么地球上的进化朝着主要进化趋势和转变的方向发展,而不是朝着任何其他方向。然而,最近,主要的生命史趋势和转变已被解释为不可避免的,这是由于一种确定性选择,它从生物体的能量状态以及在有限环境中自我复制所产生的密度依赖性竞争相互作用中展开。我描述了历史选择过程和确定性选择过程之间的异同,使用关于大体型和有限繁殖率的生命史模型来说明概念,以更广泛地关注主要进化转变的视角回顾生命史进化,并提出生物进化是由一种普遍的自然选择驱动的,其中与适应性相关性状的长期进化主要由确定性选择决定,而偶然性主要对中性性状很重要。在合适的环境条件下,研究表明,由能量状态和密度依赖性竞争相互作用导致的选择会展开为更高层次的选择,促成从简单的无性繁殖自我复制体到具有衰老现象且雌雄之间有有性繁殖的大体型生物的生命史转变,在某些情况下,还会促成进化完全的群居昆虫群体,其中有成千上万作为后代的工蚁。这为具有恒定能量流入的开放热力学系统定义了一个进化时间箭头,预测了在类似行星上长期进化的类似路径。