Basso Daniela, Guariso Graziella, Fogar Paola, Meneghel Alessandra, Zambon Carlo-Federico, Navaglia Filippo, Greco Eliana, Schiavon Stefania, Rugge Massimo, Plebani Mario
Department of Laboratory Medicine, University of Padova, Italy.
Clin Chem. 2009 Jan;55(1):150-7. doi: 10.1373/clinchem.2008.110395. Epub 2008 Nov 6.
AGA IgA II and AGA IgG II have recently been suggested as reliable tools for celiac disease (CD) diagnosis. We compared their utility for diagnosis and monitoring CD in children with that of tTG IgA, an established CD marker.
We studied a cohort of 161 CD and 129 control children in whom CD was histologically confirmed or ruled out. We followed 37 children with CD on a gluten-free diet for 12-84 months. In fasting sera, we measured AGA IgA II, AGA IgG II, and tTG IgA using ELISAs.
The best sensitivity (92.5%), specificity (97.6%), positive predictive value (98%), and negative predictive value (91.2%) were obtained using tTG IgA. AGA IgG II correctly identified 3 of 3 children with CD with total IgA deficiency who had negative AGA IgA II and tTG IgA results. In children <2 years old without total IgA deficiency, AGA IgG II and tTG IgA performed equally well (sensitivity 96.4% and specificity 100%). AGA IgA II, AGA IgG II, and tTG IgA concentrations diminished significantly (P < 0.0001) after 1 year of a gluten-free diet, reaching values below the cutoff in 87%, 70%, and 51% of cases, respectively.
The best available index for diagnosing CD in children was tTG IgA. In infants <2 years old, AGA IgG II performed as well as tTG IgA in cases without total IgA deficiency and allowed detection of CD when total IgA was <0.06 g/L. Gluten-free diet monitoring can be achieved using any of the studied serum markers.
最近有人提出,抗麦胶蛋白IgA II和抗麦胶蛋白IgG II是诊断乳糜泻(CD)的可靠工具。我们将它们在儿童CD诊断和监测中的效用与已确立的CD标志物组织转谷氨酰胺酶IgA(tTG IgA)进行了比较。
我们研究了一组161例CD患儿和129例对照儿童,这些儿童的CD通过组织学检查得以确诊或排除。我们对37例接受无麸质饮食的CD患儿进行了12 - 84个月的随访。在空腹血清中,我们使用酶联免疫吸附测定法(ELISA)检测抗麦胶蛋白IgA II、抗麦胶蛋白IgG II和tTG IgA。
使用tTG IgA获得了最佳的敏感性(92.5%)、特异性(97.6%)、阳性预测值(98%)和阴性预测值(91.2%)。抗麦胶蛋白IgG II正确识别出了3例CD伴总IgA缺乏的患儿中的3例,这3例患儿的抗麦胶蛋白IgA II和tTG IgA结果均为阴性。在2岁以下无总IgA缺乏的儿童中,抗麦胶蛋白IgG II和tTG IgA表现相当(敏感性96.4%,特异性100%)。无麸质饮食1年后,抗麦胶蛋白IgA II、抗麦胶蛋白IgG II和tTG IgA的浓度显著降低(P < 0.0001),分别有87%、70%和51%的病例降至临界值以下。
诊断儿童CD的最佳可用指标是tTG IgA。在2岁以下婴儿中,在无总IgA缺乏的情况下,抗麦胶蛋白IgG II与tTG IgA表现相当,并且当总IgA < 0.06 g/L时可检测出CD。使用任何一种研究的血清标志物都可以实现无麸质饮食监测。