Bronner Mary P, Overholt Bergein F, Taylor Shari L, Haggitt Rodger C, Wang Kenneth K, Burdick J Steven, Lightdale Charles J, Kimmey Michael, Nava Hector R, Sivak Michael V, Nishioka Norman, Barr Hugh, Canto Marcia I, Marcon Norman, Pedrosa Marcos, Grace Michael, Depot Michelle
Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio 44195, USA.
Gastroenterology. 2009 Jan;136(1):56-64; quiz 351-2. doi: 10.1053/j.gastro.2008.10.012. Epub 2008 Oct 9.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Photodynamic therapy with porfimer sodium combined with acid suppression (PHOPDT) is used to treat patients with Barrett's esophagus (BE) with high-grade dysplasia (HGD). A 5-year phase 3 trial was conducted to determine the extent of squamous overgrowth of BE with HGD after PHOPDT.
Squamous overgrowth was compared in patients with BE with HGD randomly assigned (2:1) to receive PHOPDT (n=138) or 20 mg omeprazole twice daily (n=70). Patients underwent 4-quadrant jumbo esophageal biopsies every 2 cm throughout the pretreatment length of BE until 4 consecutive quarterly follow-up results were negative for HGD and then biannually up to 5 years or treatment failure. Endoscopies were reviewed by blinded gastroenterology pathologists.
Histologic assessment of 33,658 biopsies showed no significant difference (P> .05) in squamous overgrowth between groups when compared per patient (30% vs 33%) or per biopsy (0.5% vs 1.3%), or when the average number of biopsies with squamous overgrowth were compared per patient (0.48 vs 0.66). The highest grade of neoplasia per endoscopy was not found exclusively beneath squamous mucosa in any patient.
No difference was observed in squamous overgrowth between patients given PHOPDT plus omeprazole compared with only omeprazole. Squamous overgrowth did not obscure the most advanced neoplasia in any patient. Treatment of HGD with PHOPDT in patients with BE does not present a long-term risk of failure to detect subsquamous dysplasia or carcinoma.
使用卟吩姆钠光动力疗法联合抑酸治疗(PHOPDT)来治疗伴有高级别异型增生(HGD)的巴雷特食管(BE)患者。开展了一项为期5年的3期试验,以确定PHOPDT治疗后伴有HGD的BE患者的鳞状上皮过度生长程度。
将伴有HGD的BE患者按2:1随机分组,分别接受PHOPDT(n = 138)或每日两次服用20 mg奥美拉唑(n = 70),比较两组患者的鳞状上皮过度生长情况。在BE的整个预处理长度内,每隔2 cm对患者进行4象限大活检,直至连续4个季度的随访结果显示HGD为阴性,然后每半年进行一次活检,持续5年或直至治疗失败。由不知情的胃肠病学病理学家对内镜检查结果进行评估。
对33658份活检样本进行组织学评估,结果显示,按每位患者比较(30%对33%)、按每份活检样本比较(0.5%对1.3%)或比较每位患者鳞状上皮过度生长的活检样本平均数量时(0.48对0.66),两组之间的鳞状上皮过度生长无显著差异(P > 0.05)。在任何患者中,每次内镜检查发现的最高级别的肿瘤均未仅出现在鳞状黏膜下方。
与仅接受奥美拉唑治疗的患者相比,接受PHOPDT加奥美拉唑治疗的患者在鳞状上皮过度生长方面未观察到差异。鳞状上皮过度生长并未掩盖任何患者中最严重的肿瘤。对伴有BE的患者采用PHOPDT治疗HGD不会带来未能检测到鳞状上皮下异型增生或癌的长期风险。