Hillner Bruce E, Siegel Barry A, Shields Anthony F, Liu Dawei, Gareen Ilana F, Hunt Ed, Coleman R Edward
Department of Internal Medicine, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia, USA.
J Nucl Med. 2008 Dec;49(12):1928-35. doi: 10.2967/jnumed.108.056713. Epub 2008 Nov 7.
We previously reported aggregate data showing that PET was associated with a change in intended management for over one third of patients participating in the National Oncologic PET Registry (NOPR). Here, we present results for specific cancer types and indications for testing.
The NOPR collected questionnaire data from referring physicians on intended management before and after PET. Data were available from 40,863 PET studies done at 1,368 centers. The impact of PET was assessed for 18 cancer types in patients with pathologically confirmed cancer by type and indication for testing (initial staging, restaging, or detection of suspected recurrence), other than treatment monitoring.
When intended management was classified as treatment or nontreatment, physicians changed their intended management for 38.0% of cases (95% confidence interval = 37.6%-38.5%). The frequencies of changes in management ranged from 48.7% for myeloma to 31.4% for nonmelanoma skin cancer. Comparisons across testing indications revealed that only in multiple myeloma did PET have a consistently greater impact on intended management. When the intended management plan before PET was treatment, a change in the intent of treatment (curative vs. palliative) or a major change in the modality of treatment occurred at similar frequencies across different cancer types.
The impact of PET on physicians' intended management for patients with known cancer was consistent across cancer types.
我们之前报告了汇总数据,显示正电子发射断层显像(PET)与超过三分之一参与国家肿瘤PET登记处(NOPR)的患者的预期治疗方案改变相关。在此,我们展示特定癌症类型及检测指征的结果。
NOPR收集了转诊医生关于PET检查前后预期治疗方案的问卷数据。数据来自1368个中心进行的40863项PET研究。对18种经病理确诊癌症患者的PET影响,按癌症类型及检测指征(初始分期、再分期或疑似复发检测)进行评估,不包括治疗监测。
当预期治疗方案分为治疗或不治疗时,医生对38.0%的病例改变了预期治疗方案(95%置信区间 = 37.6% - 38.5%)。治疗方案改变的频率范围从骨髓瘤的48.7%到非黑色素瘤皮肤癌的31.4%。不同检测指征的比较显示,仅在多发性骨髓瘤中,PET对预期治疗方案的影响始终更大。当PET检查前的预期治疗方案为治疗时,不同癌症类型中治疗意图(治愈性与姑息性)的改变或治疗方式的重大改变发生频率相似。
PET对已知癌症患者医生预期治疗方案的影响在不同癌症类型中是一致的。