Meierotto Lisa
University of Washington, Department of Anthropology, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
J Environ Manage. 2009 Jul;90 Suppl 3:S279-85. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2008.07.024. Epub 2008 Nov 12.
The Talo Dam was built in 2006 on the Bani River, a tributary of the Niger River in Mali. The path towards the completion of the project has been complex and controversial. This paper offers a case-study of the advocacy efforts initially opposed to, and later in support of the building of the Talo Dam. Several international institutions have been key decision-makers regarding the building of the Talo Dam, but the geographical and culture distance of the decision-making institutions to on-the-ground reality presents a serious obstacle to goals of participatory development and illustrates some inherent challenges of transnational environmental advocacy and management. Several typologies of transnational campaigns are analyzed to demonstrate the range of participation and accountability that a transnational campaign can pursue. Finally, I encourage the use of qualitative research methods by advocacy organizations as a useful methodological approach to counter otherwise inherent challenges to local inclusion and participation.
塔洛大坝于2006年建于马里境内尼日尔河的支流巴尼河上。该项目的建成之路复杂且充满争议。本文提供了一个案例研究,内容是关于最初反对、后来又支持建造塔洛大坝的宣传活动。几个国际机构一直是建造塔洛大坝的关键决策者,但决策机构与当地实际情况在地理和文化上的距离,给参与式发展目标带来了严重障碍,并说明了跨国环境宣传与管理所面临的一些内在挑战。本文分析了几种跨国运动的类型,以展示跨国运动可以追求的参与范围和问责程度。最后,我鼓励宣传组织使用定性研究方法,作为应对当地包容与参与方面固有挑战的一种有用的方法论途径。