Shaw A, Collins E E, Fakis A, Patel P, Semeraro D, Lund J N
School of Graduate Entry Medicine and Health, University of Nottingham, Derby, DE22 3DT, UK.
Tech Coloproctol. 2008 Dec;12(4):295-8. doi: 10.1007/s10151-008-0438-2. Epub 2008 Nov 18.
The aim of this study was to review lymph node retrieval from colorectal cancer resections.
We examined consecutive, single colorectal cancers excised between September 1999 and February 2007. Data gathered included patient age and gender, cancer location, total number of lymph nodes and involved lymph nodes identified. The speciality of the operating surgeon was recorded. Whether a pathologist or biomedical scientist was responsible for harvesting lymph nodes from the resected specimen was also noted.
A total of 1,194 patients were identified. Increased numbers of lymph nodes identified was associated with increased lymph node positivity (p<0.001, r=0.121). Biomedical scientists identified more lymph nodes (median 15, range 12-20) within specimens than consultant pathologists (median 10, range 7-13; p<0.001). Colorectal surgeons removed more lymph nodes (median 11, range 7-15) than non-colorectal surgeons (median 9, range 7-14; p=0.002).
There was a significant increase in lymph node harvesting over time and this correlated with lymph node positivity. Lymph node harvest was significantly higher when the resection was performed by a colorectal surgeon and when the specimen was examined by a biomedical scientist. For accurate staging and consequent correct planning of adjuvant treatment and prognosis, resections should be performed by a colorectal surgeon and the lymph nodes harvested by a biomedical scientist.
本研究旨在回顾结直肠癌切除术中的淋巴结清扫情况。
我们检查了1999年9月至2007年2月间连续切除的单发结直肠癌病例。收集的数据包括患者年龄和性别、癌症位置、识别出的淋巴结总数和受累淋巴结数。记录手术医生的专业。还记录了病理学家或生物医学科学家是否负责从切除标本中获取淋巴结。
共识别出1194例患者。识别出的淋巴结数量增加与淋巴结阳性率增加相关(p<0.001,r=0.121)。生物医学科学家在标本中识别出的淋巴结(中位数15,范围12 - 20)比顾问病理学家多(中位数10,范围7 - 13;p<0.001)。结直肠外科医生清扫的淋巴结(中位数11,范围7 - 15)比非结直肠外科医生多(中位数9,范围7 - 14;p = 0.002)。
随着时间推移,淋巴结清扫数量显著增加,且这与淋巴结阳性率相关。当由结直肠外科医生进行切除手术且标本由生物医学科学家检查时,淋巴结清扫率显著更高。为了准确分期以及随后正确规划辅助治疗和判断预后,切除手术应由结直肠外科医生进行,淋巴结应由生物医学科学家获取。