Louis Elan D, Rios Eileen
GH Sergievsky Center, College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2009 Aug;15(7):535-8. doi: 10.1016/j.parkreldis.2008.10.006. Epub 2008 Nov 22.
Embarrassment is a commonly described feature of essential tremor (ET) but has not been the focus of clinical research.
To estimate the prevalence, identify susceptible patient groups, and quantify the therapeutic correlates of reported embarrassment.
A total of 106 ET cases from a population-based sample and 349 ET cases from a clinical sample were asked, "Does your tremor often embarrass you?"
In the clinical sample, the prevalence of embarrassment was high (58.2%). Even in those ET cases with no head tremor and mild arm tremor, nearly one-half (29/61 [47.5%]) reported embarrassment. While the prevalence of embarrassment was lower in the population-based sample, it was not negligible (18.9%). Embarrassment was associated with younger age of onset (p=0.003) and women were nearly twice as likely as men to report embarrassment (OR=1.85, p=0.01). Independent of tremor severity, embarrassment nearly doubled the odds of using tremor medication (OR=1.86, p=0.01).
Embarrassment may be a source of disability in ET. Even among clinic patients with mild tremor, nearly one-half reported embarrassment. We identified a number of patient characteristics linked to embarrassment. Embarrassment alone (i.e., independent of tremor severity) was responsible for a doubling of tremor medication usage. The majority of clinical trials do not assess the therapeutic effects of medication on embarrassment. These trials may benefit from scaled assessments of level of embarrassment.
尴尬是特发性震颤(ET)常见的一种表现,但尚未成为临床研究的重点。
评估尴尬的患病率,确定易感患者群体,并量化所报告尴尬的治疗相关性。
对来自基于人群样本的106例ET患者和来自临床样本的349例ET患者询问:“你的震颤是否经常让你感到尴尬?”
在临床样本中,尴尬的患病率很高(58.2%)。即使在那些没有头部震颤且手臂震颤较轻的ET患者中,近一半(29/61[47.5%])报告有尴尬感。虽然在基于人群的样本中尴尬的患病率较低,但也不可忽视(18.9%)。尴尬与发病年龄较轻有关(p=0.003),女性报告尴尬的可能性几乎是男性的两倍(OR=1.85,p=0.01)。与震颤严重程度无关,尴尬使使用震颤药物的几率几乎增加了一倍(OR=1.86,p=0.01)。
尴尬可能是ET患者残疾的一个来源。即使在震颤较轻的门诊患者中,近一半也报告有尴尬感。我们确定了一些与尴尬相关的患者特征。仅尴尬(即与震颤严重程度无关)就导致震颤药物使用量增加一倍。大多数临床试验并未评估药物对尴尬感的治疗效果。这些试验可能会受益于对尴尬程度的分级评估。