Degrave Etienne, Meeusen Ben, Grivegnée André-Robert, Boniol Mathieu, Autier Philippe
Unit of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Military Hospital Brussels, Brussels, Belgium.
Int J Cancer. 2009 Feb 15;124(4):945-51. doi: 10.1002/ijc.23988.
Concerns have been raised about the safety of the electromagnetic (microwave) emissions of radars, as well as about the ionizing radiation that is emitted on short distances (<2 m) by devices in the radars producing the microwaves. We retrospectively compared the cause specific mortality of 4,417 Belgian professional male military personnel who served in anti-aircraft radar units in Germany between 1963 and 1994 to the cause specific mortality of 2,932 Belgian military personnel who served at the same time in the same place in battalions not equipped with radars. Mean follow-up was 26 years in the 2 groups. Age-adjusted rate ratio (RR) and 95% confidence intervals were derived from a Poisson regression model. Four hundred twenty-four deaths in the battalions groups and 271 deaths in the control battalions occurred (RR = 1.04 (0.96-1.14)). For specific causes of deaths, RRs were 1.22 (1.03-1.47) for neoplasms and 3.51 (1.19-10.3) for symptoms, signs and ill defined conditions. RRs for other causes of death were not significantly different from 1.00. Among deaths from neoplasms, RR for hemolymphatic cancer was 7.22 (1.09-47.9). RRs for other causes of cancer deaths were not significantly different from 1.00. The results for specific tumor types were all based on very small numbers. The RR for cancer increased with decreasing age and suggested that the RR for cancer increased with the duration of stay in radar battalions. In conclusion, exposure of professional military personnel to anti-aircraft radars that existed in Western Europe from the 1960s until the 1990s may have resulted in an increase in the incidence of hemolymphatic cancers. It remains to be established whether this increase is due to microwaves generated by radars or ionizing radiation produced by electronic devices producing the microwaves.
人们已经对雷达的电磁(微波)辐射安全性表示担忧,同时也关注雷达中产生微波的设备在短距离(<2米)内发出的电离辐射。我们回顾性比较了1963年至1994年间在德国防空雷达部队服役的4417名比利时职业男性军事人员的死因别死亡率,与同期在同一地点未配备雷达的营中服役的2932名比利时军事人员的死因别死亡率。两组的平均随访时间为26年。年龄调整率比(RR)和95%置信区间来自泊松回归模型。营组中有424人死亡,对照组中有271人死亡(RR = 1.04(0.96 - 1.14))。对于特定死因,肿瘤的RR为1.22(1.03 - 1.47),症状、体征和未明确诊断的疾病的RR为3.51(1.19 - 10.3)。其他死因的RR与1.00无显著差异。在肿瘤死亡中,血液淋巴癌的RR为7.22(1.09 - 47.9)。其他癌症死因的RR与1.00无显著差异。特定肿瘤类型的结果均基于非常小的样本量。癌症的RR随年龄降低而增加,表明癌症的RR随在雷达营的停留时间增加而增加。总之,20世纪60年代至90年代西欧存在的防空雷达使职业军事人员暴露,可能导致血液淋巴癌发病率增加。这种增加是否归因于雷达产生的微波或产生微波的电子设备产生的电离辐射,仍有待确定。