Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Shinanomachi 35, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo 160-8582, Japan.
J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2010 Jan;63(1):9-14. doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2008.08.071. Epub 2008 Dec 5.
Anthropometric evaluation of cleft lip nasal growth has generally been done based on Mulliken's method. However, this method does not allow sufficient evaluation of nasal tip position. Nasal tip position is the most important parameter for evaluation of nasal growth. Therefore, an anthropometric study was performed including vertical nasal tip position.
Fifteen normal subjects in early childhood (Normal Group), 15 age-matched subjects with complete unilateral cleft lip and alveolus or complete unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate without rhinoplasty (No Rhinoplasty Group), and 16 age-matched subjects with complete unilateral cleft lip and alveolus or complete unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate with synchronous rhinoplasty during primary repair of cleft lip (Primary Rhinoplasty Group) were compared. Nasolabial angle (beta), nasal tip angle (alpha), nasal width (al-al), columellar length (sn-c'), nasal tip protrusion (sn-prn), and vertical nasal tip position (sn'-prn'/sn'-n') were measured.
With the exception of vertical nasal tip position, the measurement data of the Primary Rhinoplasty Group were excellent. In the cleft lip groups, vertical nasal tip position was significantly higher than that in the Normal Group.
Our results showed that the nasal tips of cleft lip patients showed significant congenital upward deviation in comparison with normal children. In Mulliken's method, this upward deviation cannot be evaluated properly. After synchronous rhinoplasty, measurement results showed improvement in our patients without significant deterioration of tip position. These findings represent evidence in support of synchronous rhinoplasty.
唇裂鼻生长的人体测量评估通常基于 Mulliken 法进行。然而,这种方法无法充分评估鼻尖位置。鼻尖位置是评估鼻生长最重要的参数。因此,进行了一项包括垂直鼻尖位置的人体测量研究。
比较了 15 名早期正常儿童(正常组)、15 名年龄匹配的单侧完全唇裂伴牙槽裂或单侧完全唇裂、牙槽裂和腭裂且未行鼻整形术的患者(无鼻整形组)和 16 名年龄匹配的单侧完全唇裂伴牙槽裂或单侧完全唇裂、牙槽裂和腭裂且在唇裂一期修复时同期行鼻整形术的患者(一期鼻整形组)。测量了鼻唇角(β)、鼻尖角(α)、鼻宽(al-al)、鼻中隔长度(sn-c')、鼻尖突出度(sn-prn)和垂直鼻尖位置(sn'-prn'/sn'-n')。
除垂直鼻尖位置外,一期鼻整形组的测量数据均较好。在唇裂组中,垂直鼻尖位置明显高于正常组。
我们的结果表明,与正常儿童相比,唇裂患者的鼻尖存在明显的先天性向上偏斜。在 Mulliken 法中,这种向上偏斜不能得到适当评估。同期行鼻整形术后,我们的患者的测量结果得到了改善,而鼻尖位置没有明显恶化。这些发现为同期鼻整形术提供了支持证据。