Pincus T, Swearingen C J, Luta G, Sokka T
Department of Rheumatology, New York University-Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York, NY 10003, USA.
Ann Rheum Dis. 2009 Nov;68(11):1715-20. doi: 10.1136/ard.2008.095539. Epub 2008 Dec 15.
A randomised double-blind placebo controlled withdrawal clinical trial of prednisone versus placebo in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), treated in usual clinical care with 1-4 mg/day prednisone, withdrawn to the same dose of 1 mg prednisone or identical placebo tablets.
All patients were from one academic setting and all trial visits were conducted in usual clinical care. Patients were taking stable doses of 1-4 mg prednisone with stable clinical status, documented quantitatively by patient questionnaire scores. The protocol included three phases: (1) equivalence: 1-4 study prednisone 1 mg tablets taken for 12 weeks to ascertain their efficacy compared with the patient's usual tablets before randomisation; (2) transfer: substitution of a 1 mg prednisone or identical placebo tablet every 4 weeks (over 0-12 weeks) to the same number as baseline prednisone; (3) comparison: observation over 24 subsequent weeks taking the same number of either placebo or prednisone tablets as at baseline. The primary outcome was withdrawal due to patient-reported lack of efficacy versus continuation in the trial for 24 weeks.
Thirty-one patients were randomised, 15 to prednisone and 16 to placebo, with three administrative discontinuations. In "intent-to-treat" analyses, 3/15 prednisone and 11/16 placebo participants withdrew (p = 0.03). Among participants eligible for the primary outcome, 3/13 prednisone and 11/15 placebo participants withdrew for lack of efficacy (p = 0.02). No meaningful adverse events were reported, as anticipated.
Efficacy of 1-4 mg prednisone was documented. Evidence of statistically significant differences with only 31 patients may suggest a robust treatment effect.
一项关于类风湿关节炎(RA)患者的随机双盲安慰剂对照撤药临床试验,这些患者在常规临床护理中接受1 - 4毫克/天的泼尼松治疗,撤药后改为相同剂量的1毫克泼尼松或相同的安慰剂片。
所有患者均来自一个学术机构,所有试验访视均在常规临床护理中进行。患者服用稳定剂量的1 - 4毫克泼尼松且临床状态稳定,通过患者问卷评分进行定量记录。该方案包括三个阶段:(1)等效性:服用1 - 4片研究用泼尼松1毫克片剂,持续12周,以确定与随机分组前患者常用片剂相比的疗效;(2)转换:每4周(在0 - 12周内)将1毫克泼尼松或相同的安慰剂片替换为与基线泼尼松数量相同的片剂;(3)比较:在随后的24周内进行观察,服用与基线相同数量的安慰剂或泼尼松片。主要结局是因患者报告缺乏疗效而撤药与在试验中持续24周的情况。
31名患者被随机分组,15名接受泼尼松治疗,16名接受安慰剂治疗,有3例因管理原因停药。在“意向性治疗”分析中,15名泼尼松治疗参与者中有3名、16名安慰剂治疗参与者中有11名撤药(p = 0.03)。在符合主要结局的参与者中,13名泼尼松治疗参与者中有3名、15名安慰剂治疗参与者中有11名因缺乏疗效而撤药(p = 0.02)。如预期的那样,未报告有意义的不良事件。
记录了1 - 4毫克泼尼松的疗效。仅31名患者就有统计学显著差异的证据,这可能表明存在强大的治疗效果。