Chande Nilesh, MacDonald John K, McDonald John W D
Division of Gastroenterology, London Health Sciences Centre, The University of Western Ontario, South Street Hospital, 375 South St., London, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Gastroenterol. 2009 Jan;104(1):235-41; quiz 234, 242. doi: 10.1038/ajg.2008.16.
To conduct a systematic review to determine effective treatments for patients with collagenous colitis or lymphocytic colitis, the two subtypes of microscopic colitis.
Relevant papers were identified via the MEDLINE, PUBMED, and Cochrane Collaboration databases, manual searches of the references of identified papers and review papers on microscopic colitis, as well as searches of abstracts from major gastroenterological meetings.
All studies assessing treatment of microscopic colitis had relatively small sample sizes. A total of 10 randomized trials included patients with collagenous colitis. Budesonide was studied for induction of response in three trials and for maintenance of response in two trials. The pooled odds ratio for inducing clinical response with budesonide was 12.32 (95% confidence interval, CI 5.53-27.46), and for maintaining clinical response was 8.82 (95% CI 3.19-24.37), with a number needed to treat (NNT) of 2 patients for each outcome. Budesonide also induced and maintained histological response and was well tolerated. Bismuth subsalicylate, prednisolone, and mesalamine with or without cholestyramine may be effective, whereas Boswellia serrata extract and probiotics were ineffective for treating collagenous colitis. Three randomized trials included patients with lymphocytic colitis. Budesonide was shown in one study to be effective for inducing clinical response (OR 9.00; 95% CI 1.98-40.93), with an NNT of three patients. Budesonide also induced histological response and was well tolerated. Bismuth subsalicylate and mesalamine with or without cholestyramine may be effective for treating lymphocytic colitis. No trials assessed maintenance of response in patients with lymphocytic colitis.
Budesonide is effective and well tolerated for inducing and maintaining clinical and histological responses in patients with collagenous colitis, and for inducing clinical and histological responses in patients with lymphocytic colitis. Determining the magnitude of benefit is limited by the small sample sizes of the studies. The evidence for other agents, including bismuth subsalicylate, prednisolone, B. serrata extract, probiotics, and mesalamine with or without cholestyramine is weaker. It is not clear that any of these agents induce or maintain actual remission of collagenous or lymphocytic colitis, as opposed to clinical or histological response.
进行一项系统评价,以确定胶原性结肠炎或淋巴细胞性结肠炎(显微镜下结肠炎的两种亚型)患者的有效治疗方法。
通过MEDLINE、PUBMED和Cochrane协作网数据库、对已识别论文及显微镜下结肠炎综述论文参考文献的手工检索以及对主要胃肠病学会议摘要的检索来识别相关论文。
所有评估显微镜下结肠炎治疗的研究样本量相对较小。共有10项随机试验纳入了胶原性结肠炎患者。三项试验研究了布地奈德诱导缓解情况,两项试验研究了其维持缓解情况。布地奈德诱导临床缓解的合并比值比为12.32(95%置信区间,CI 5.53 - 27.46),维持临床缓解的合并比值比为8.82(95%CI 3.19 - 24.37),每个结局的治疗所需人数(NNT)为2例患者。布地奈德还可诱导并维持组织学缓解,且耐受性良好。水杨酸铋、泼尼松龙以及联用或不联用考来烯胺的美沙拉嗪可能有效,而锯叶棕提取物和益生菌治疗胶原性结肠炎无效。三项随机试验纳入了淋巴细胞性结肠炎患者。一项研究显示布地奈德诱导临床缓解有效(OR 9.00;95%CI 1.98 - 40.93),NNT为3例患者。布地奈德还可诱导组织学缓解,且耐受性良好。水杨酸铋以及联用或不联用考来烯胺的美沙拉嗪可能有效治疗淋巴细胞性结肠炎。尚无试验评估淋巴细胞性结肠炎患者的缓解维持情况。
布地奈德在诱导和维持胶原性结肠炎患者的临床及组织学缓解以及诱导淋巴细胞性结肠炎患者的临床及组织学缓解方面有效且耐受性良好。研究样本量较小限制了对获益程度的判定。包括水杨酸铋、泼尼松龙、锯叶棕提取物、益生菌以及联用或不联用考来烯胺的美沙拉嗪等其他药物的证据较弱。与临床或组织学缓解不同,目前尚不清楚这些药物中任何一种能否诱导或维持胶原性或淋巴细胞性结肠炎的实际缓解。