Ruiz M T, Alvarez-Dardet C, Vela P, Pascual E
Community Health Department, University of Alicante, Spain.
Br J Rheumatol. 1991 Oct;30(5):352-5. doi: 10.1093/rheumatology/30.5.352.
In order to determine the characteristics of papers published in the rheumatological literature, we have conducted a survey of the seven leading rheumatological journals published in 1987; 1107 original papers have been reviewed and classified according to study design, statistical techniques, and country of origin. Almost half of the published papers were clinical descriptive studies without inferential power; both authors and editors should reflect whether the impact of these studies on the knowledge of readers justifies their frequency. Analytical research was represented mainly by randomized clinical trials (15.6%), and case control studies (14.2%). Cohort studies represented 5.4% and this seems a low figure in a specialty in need of more aetiological research. Almost half of the papers originated from the USA or the UK; journals edited in these countries published papers mainly from the same country. English language journals from other countries published a larger percentage of papers from other countries, including many non-English speaking nations. Bibliometric studies are desirable to evaluate trends in publication.
为了确定发表在风湿病学文献中的论文的特点,我们对1987年出版的七种主要风湿病学杂志进行了一项调查;已根据研究设计、统计技术和原产国对1107篇原创论文进行了审查和分类。几乎一半发表的论文是没有推理能力的临床描述性研究;作者和编辑都应该思考这些研究对读者知识的影响是否证明了它们出现的频率是合理的。分析性研究主要由随机临床试验(15.6%)和病例对照研究(14.2%)代表。队列研究占5.4%,在一个需要更多病因学研究的专业领域中,这似乎是一个较低的数字。几乎一半的论文来自美国或英国;在这些国家编辑的杂志主要发表来自同一国家的论文。来自其他国家的英语杂志发表的来自其他国家的论文比例更高,包括许多非英语国家。计量文献学研究对于评估出版趋势是很有必要的。