Kondo M, Hoshi S-L, Toi M
Department of Health Care Policy and Management, Graduate School of Comprehensive Human Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan.
Br J Cancer. 2009 Jan 27;100(2):281-90. doi: 10.1038/sj.bjc.6604869. Epub 2009 Jan 13.
Raloxifene was approved for chemoprevention against breast cancer among high-risk women in addition to tamoxifen by the US Food and Drug Administration. This study aims to evaluate cost-effectiveness of these agents under Japan's health system. A cost-effectiveness analysis with Markov model consisting of eight health states such as healthy, invasive breast cancer, and endometrial cancer is carried out. The model incorporated the findings of National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project P-1 and P-2 trial, and key costs obtained from health insurance claim reviews. Favourable results, that is cost saving or cost-effective, are found by both tamoxifen and raloxifene for the introduction of chemoprevention among extremely high-risk women such as having a history of atypical hyperplasia, a history of lobular carcinoma in situ or a 5-year predicted breast cancer risk of > or =5.01% starting at younger age, whereas unfavourable results, that is 'cost more and gain less' or cost-ineffective, are found for women with a 5-year predicted breast cancer risk of < or =5.00%. Therapeutic policy switch from tamoxifen to raloxifene among postmenopausal women are implied cost-effective. Findings suggest that introduction of chemoprevention targeting extremely high-risk women in Japan can be justifiable as an efficient use of finite health-care resources, possibly contributing to cost containment.
除他莫昔芬外,雷洛昔芬已被美国食品药品监督管理局批准用于高危女性预防乳腺癌。本研究旨在评估在日本医疗体系下这些药物的成本效益。开展了一项采用马尔可夫模型的成本效益分析,该模型包含健康、浸润性乳腺癌和子宫内膜癌等八种健康状态。该模型纳入了国家外科辅助乳腺和肠道项目P-1和P-2试验的结果,以及从医疗保险理赔审查中获得的关键成本。对于极高危女性(如有非典型增生病史、小叶原位癌病史或从年轻时起5年预测乳腺癌风险≥5.01%)引入化学预防,他莫昔芬和雷洛昔芬均取得了有利结果,即节省成本或具有成本效益;而对于5年预测乳腺癌风险≤5.00%的女性,则得出了不利结果,即“成本更高且获益更少”或成本无效。绝经后女性从他莫昔芬转为雷洛昔芬的治疗策略转变在成本效益方面是合理的。研究结果表明,在日本针对极高危女性引入化学预防作为有限医疗资源的有效利用是合理的,可能有助于控制成本。