Kaur Balvinder, Rowe Brian H, Arnold Elizabeth
Bartholomew House, Birmingham, UK.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009 Jan 21;2009(1):CD000993. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000993.pub3.
Vitamin C is one of the key antioxidant vitamins which is abundant in the extracellular fluid lining the lung and low vitamin C intake has been associated with pulmonary dysfunction.
To evaluate the evidence for the efficacy of vitamin C in the treatment of asthma.
The Cochrane Airways Review Group asthma register was searched and bibliographies of studies identified were also checked for further trials. This review has been updated by searches to August 2008.
Only randomised controlled trials were eligible for inclusion. Studies were considered for inclusion if they dealt with the treatment of asthma using vitamin C supplementation. Two independent reviewers identified potentially relevant studies using pre-defined criteria and selected studies for inclusion.
Data were abstracted independently by two reviewers. Information on patients, methods, interventions, outcomes and results was extracted using standard forms.
Nine studies met the review entry criteria, randomising a total of 330 participants. Study design varied and the reporting was generally poor. Five trials contributed numerical data to the review. They provided outcome data on lung function, symptom scores, IgE levels and inhaled steroid use. One small study showed a significant difference in % drop in FEV1 post-exercise.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: At present, evidence from randomised-controlled trials is insufficient to recommend a specific role for vitamin C in the treatment of asthma. Further methodologically strong and large-scale randomised controlled trials are needed in order to address the question of the effectiveness of vitamin C in children with asthma.
维生素C是关键的抗氧化维生素之一,在肺脏内衬的细胞外液中含量丰富,而维生素C摄入不足与肺功能障碍有关。
评估维生素C治疗哮喘疗效的证据。
检索了Cochrane气道综述组哮喘登记库,并对所识别研究的参考文献进行检查以查找更多试验。本综述已更新至2008年8月的检索结果。
仅纳入随机对照试验。若研究涉及使用补充维生素C治疗哮喘,则考虑纳入。两名独立评审员使用预先确定的标准识别潜在相关研究,并选择纳入研究。
两名评审员独立提取数据。使用标准表格提取有关患者、方法、干预措施、结局和结果的信息。
9项研究符合综述纳入标准,共纳入330名参与者。研究设计各异,报告质量普遍较差。5项试验为综述提供了数值数据。它们提供了肺功能、症状评分、IgE水平和吸入类固醇使用情况的结局数据。一项小型研究显示运动后FEV1下降百分比存在显著差异。
目前,随机对照试验的证据不足以推荐维生素C在哮喘治疗中的特定作用。需要进一步开展方法学严谨的大规模随机对照试验,以解决维生素C对哮喘儿童有效性的问题。