Scott Apryl S, Parr Luke A, Johnstone Peter A S
Department of Radiation Oncology, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
Radiother Oncol. 2009 Feb;90(2):163-5. doi: 10.1016/j.radonc.2008.12.019. Epub 2009 Jan 24.
Although low dose radiation therapy (RT) has been used to prevent re-occlusion of coronary arteries, it may also precipitate vascular damage. Specifically, irradiation to the neck is related to subsequent vascular wall thickening and atherosclerotic plaque formation. Several investigators, reporting patients with varied disease processes and using different methods, have described an increased risk of cerebrovascular events (CVEs) after RT to the neck for head and neck cancer, breast cancer, or lymphoma. Our purpose is to determine the rate and risk of CVEs in patients after receiving radiation therapy to the neck.
We performed a pooled analysis of the published data to document the cumulative risk of subsequent stroke after RT to the neck. An extensive MEDLINE and PUBMED search yielded five articles involving 6908 patients describing institutional series or cohort analyses comparing the frequency of CVE in irradiated versus non-irradiated patients.
Sixty-six CVEs were reported in 2567 patients after neck RT, whereas only 12 CVEs were documented in 4119 non-irradiated patients. Crude risk of CVEs after neck RT was 2.6%, and was 0.29% in non-irradiated patients. This odds ratio of 9.0 was statistically significant (95% CI 4.9, 16.7; p<0.0001). Data for supraclavicular RT were more difficult to analyze given differences in populations and reporting between the three studies, but it appears a significant risk is unlikely.
Neck RT increases the likelihood of CVEs, but this risk must be reconciled with the benefits of the therapy in the specific clinical situation. For instance, consideration should be made to limiting neck RT where possible for breast cancer and lymphoma patients.
尽管低剂量放射治疗(RT)已被用于预防冠状动脉再闭塞,但它也可能引发血管损伤。具体而言,颈部照射与随后的血管壁增厚和动脉粥样硬化斑块形成有关。几位研究者报告了患有不同疾病进程的患者,并采用了不同方法,描述了对头颈部癌、乳腺癌或淋巴瘤患者进行颈部放疗后脑血管事件(CVE)风险增加。我们的目的是确定接受颈部放疗患者发生CVE的发生率和风险。
我们对已发表的数据进行汇总分析,以记录颈部放疗后后续中风的累积风险。广泛的MEDLINE和PUBMED检索产生了五篇文章,涉及6908名患者,描述了机构系列研究或队列分析,比较了接受照射与未接受照射患者的CVE发生频率。
2567例患者颈部放疗后报告了66例CVE,而4119例未接受照射的患者中仅记录了12例CVE。颈部放疗后CVE的粗风险为2.6%,未接受照射患者为0.29%。9.0的优势比具有统计学意义(95%CI 4.9,16.7;p<0.0001)。鉴于三项研究人群和报告存在差异,锁骨上放疗的数据更难分析,但似乎不太可能存在显著风险。
颈部放疗增加了CVE的可能性,但这种风险必须与特定临床情况下治疗的益处相权衡。例如,对于乳腺癌和淋巴瘤患者,应考虑尽可能限制颈部放疗。