Sketris Ingrid S, Langille Ingram Ethel M, Lummis Heather L
Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Can J Clin Pharmacol. 2009 Winter;16(1):e103-25. Epub 2009 Jan 30.
Canadians receive over 422 million prescriptions and spend over $26 billion annually on drugs. Yet, we do not systematically capture information on whether the right drugs reach the right people with the intended benefits, while avoiding unintended harm. It is important to identify and understand the effectiveness of approaches used to improve prescribing and medication use.
To discuss the medication-use system, identify factors affecting prescribing, and assess effectiveness of interventions.
A literature review was conducted using electronic databases, federal agencies', provincial health departments', health service delivery organizations' and Canadian health research organizations' websites, the Internet, and some hand searching. Interventions identified were categorized according to the Effective Practice and Organization of Care Group (EPOC) classification, with effectiveness based on the literature.
Factors affecting prescribing relate to the patient and society, medication, prescriber, practice environment and organization, available information and other external factors. Interventions reported as generally effective are multi-faceted interventions, academic detailing, and reminders. Interventions reported as sometimes effective are audit and feedback or physician profiling, local opinion leaders, drug utilization review, and local consensus guidelines. Passive dissemination of educational materials is deemed generally ineffective.
No single approach is appropriate for every prescribing problem, health professional prescriber practice or health care setting. Interventions to improve prescribing in community and institutional settings have variable effect sizes. Effectiveness is related to content, delivery mechanisms, intensity, intervention's context, and implementation environment. Even an intervention with a small effect size (< 10%) may yield important changes in drug use when applied on a population basis. Further research and evaluation is needed to determine how or why the interventions work and identify barriers to effective implementation.
加拿大人每年收到超过4.22亿张处方,在药品上的花费超过260亿加元。然而,我们并未系统地收集关于正确的药物是否给到了正确的人并带来预期益处、同时避免意外伤害的信息。识别并理解用于改善处方开具和药物使用的方法的有效性很重要。
讨论药物使用系统,识别影响处方开具的因素,并评估干预措施的有效性。
通过电子数据库、联邦机构网站、省级卫生部门网站、卫生服务提供组织网站、加拿大卫生研究组织网站、互联网以及一些手工检索进行文献综述。根据有效实践与护理组织小组(EPOC)分类对识别出的干预措施进行分类,并依据文献确定其有效性。
影响处方开具的因素涉及患者和社会、药物、开处方者、实践环境与组织、可用信息及其他外部因素。报告显示通常有效的干预措施有多方面干预、学术详述和提醒。报告显示有时有效的干预措施有审核与反馈或医生剖析、当地意见领袖、药物利用审查以及当地共识指南。教育材料的被动传播通常被认为无效。
没有单一的方法适用于每一个处方开具问题、卫生专业开处方者的实践或医疗保健环境。改善社区和机构环境中处方开具的干预措施效果大小各异。有效性与内容、传播机制、强度、干预背景及实施环境有关。即使是效果大小较小(<10%)的干预措施,在应用于总体人群时也可能在药物使用方面产生重要变化。需要进一步的研究和评估来确定干预措施如何起作用或为何起作用,并识别有效实施的障碍。