Tamblyn R M, Jacques A, Laprise R, Huang A, Perreault R
Quebec Research Group on Medication Use in the Elderly, Royal Victoria Hospital, Montreal, Canada.
Clin Perform Qual Health Care. 1997 Apr-Jun;5(2):104-8.
Effective management of drug therapy in the elderly is a challenge for primary-care physicians. There are 20,400 drugs approved for marketing in Canada. Most elderly patients will fill 33 prescriptions per year and take 5 different medications. To be a safe prescriber in the 1990s, physicians need to be aware that 33,000 drug interactions, 6,500 drug-disease contraindications, and 3,500 drug-allergy contraindications have been documented. Inappropriate prescribing is a problem in the elderly. At least one inappropriate prescription is given to 12% to 46% of seniors, and 25% of drug-related hospital admissions are due to prescribing errors. Half of all physicians will write at least one inappropriate prescription for an elderly patient each year, and one quarter of inappropriate prescriptions will be created by the presence of multiple prescribing physicians. Academic detailing is the most effective approach to improve physician prescribing. However, it is an expensive intervention that must be limited to a small number of drugs and conditions, and it must be continued to retain its effectiveness. Furthermore, it fails to address the problems created by multiple prescribers. In this project, we developed a prototype of the future office practice. Physicians are equipped with personal computers and expert prescribing-system software. This electronic academic detailer reviews all current medications for a patient, identifies therapeutic duplications, generates alerts for 50 prescribing problems that have been identified as clinically relevant by a Canadian expert panel, suggests suitable alternatives, and reviews all new prescriptions for potential problems. Information on all prescriptions received by the physicians' elderly patients is downloaded weekly from the provincial prescription claims database, so that the primary physician is able to coordinate and manage all drugs prescribed to their patients by all physicians. The effectiveness of this intervention is being evaluated in a randomized controlled trial of 110 physicians and approximately 16,000 elderly patients in Montreal. We will test whether the intervention reduces the rate of inappropriate prescribing, as well as the rate of drug-related injuries and hospitalizations among patients treated by physicians in the experimental group.
对基层医疗医生来说,有效管理老年患者的药物治疗是一项挑战。加拿大有20400种药物获批上市。大多数老年患者每年会拿到33张处方,服用5种不同药物。要在20世纪90年代成为一名安全的开方医生,医生需要意识到已有33000种药物相互作用、6500种药物与疾病禁忌以及3500种药物过敏禁忌被记录在案。不恰当开药是老年患者面临的一个问题。至少12%至46%的老年人会收到至少一张不恰当处方,25%与药物相关的住院病例是由开药错误导致的。所有医生中,每年有一半会给老年患者至少开一张不恰当处方,四分之一的不恰当处方是由多名开方医生共同造成的。学术指导是改善医生开药行为最有效的方法。然而,这是一项昂贵的干预措施,必须局限于少数药物和病症,而且必须持续进行才能保持效果。此外,它无法解决多名开方医生造成的问题。在这个项目中,我们开发了一个未来门诊实践的原型。医生配备了个人电脑和专业开药系统软件。这个电子学术指导工具会查看患者目前服用的所有药物,识别治疗重复情况,针对加拿大专家小组认定具有临床相关性的50个开药问题发出警报,建议合适的替代药物,并查看所有新处方是否存在潜在问题。医生的老年患者收到的所有处方信息每周从省级处方报销数据库下载,这样初级医生就能协调和管理所有医生给其患者开的所有药物。目前正在蒙特利尔对110名医生和大约16000名老年患者进行一项随机对照试验,以评估这种干预措施的效果。我们将测试该干预措施是否能降低不恰当开药率,以及实验组医生治疗的患者中与药物相关的伤害和住院率。