Glendor Ulf
Department of Medicine and Society, Division of Social Medicine and Public Health Science, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden.
Dent Traumatol. 2009 Feb;25(1):12-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-9657.2008.00707.x.
BACKGROUND/AIM: Several reports have been published during the past decades showing a lack of care of traumatic dental injuries (TDIs) as well as dentists and lay people having insufficient knowledge on how to manage TDIs. This situation could seriously affect the outcome of TDIs, especially a complicated TDI. The overall aim of this study was to present a review of dental trauma care with focus on treatment and dentists and lay persons' lack of knowledge on how to manage a TDI. A further aim is to introduce the actors involved and the outcome of their education.
The databases Medline, Cochrane, SSCI, SCI and CINAHL from the year 1995 to the present were used. Focus was on treatment need, inadequate care, lack of knowledge and poor organization of emergency care.
Studies from different countries demonstrated that treatment needs were not properly met despite the fact that not all untreated teeth needed treatment. Treatment in emergency dental care was often inadequate or inappropriate. With the exception of lay people, teachers, medical personnel and even dentists performed inadequate care. Furthermore, information to the public was insufficient. Despite a low level of knowledge, lay people expressed a strong interest in helping someone with a TDI.
The conclusion from this review is that consideration must be given the problematic results from different studies on education or information about dental trauma care. Despite that the studies reviewed were from different countries and groups of people, the results seem to be consistent, i.e. that a large part of the educational process of professional caregivers and lay people has failed. Too much hope seems to be put on lay people to handle difficult cases such as tooth avulsion. Education of caregivers and lay people is a field where much remains to be explored.
背景/目的:在过去几十年间,已有多篇报道指出对创伤性牙损伤(TDI)缺乏护理,并且牙医和普通民众在如何处理TDI方面知识不足。这种情况可能会严重影响TDI的治疗结果,尤其是复杂的TDI。本研究的总体目的是对牙外伤护理进行综述,重点关注治疗以及牙医和普通民众在如何处理TDI方面的知识欠缺。另一个目的是介绍相关参与者及其教育成果。
使用了1995年至今的Medline、Cochrane、SSCI、SCI和CINAHL数据库。重点关注治疗需求、护理不足、知识缺乏以及急诊护理组织不善等方面。
来自不同国家的研究表明,尽管并非所有未治疗的牙齿都需要治疗,但治疗需求并未得到妥善满足。急诊牙科护理中的治疗往往不足或不恰当。除了普通民众外,教师、医务人员甚至牙医的护理也都存在不足。此外,向公众提供的信息也不够充分。尽管知识水平较低,但普通民众表示非常愿意帮助TDI患者。
本次综述的结论是,必须考虑不同研究中关于牙外伤护理教育或信息方面存在的问题结果。尽管所综述的研究来自不同国家和人群,但结果似乎是一致的,即专业护理人员和普通民众的大部分教育过程都失败了。似乎对普通民众处理诸如牙齿脱位等困难病例寄予了太多希望。护理人员和普通民众的教育是一个仍有许多有待探索的领域。